Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Is this the true religion?
by Arjun Periyar on Oct 04, 2007 02:30 PM   Permalink | Hide replies

Dear Ismail,

I regret to say again that you are still not addressing the basic issue. You are writing about all other things which are not relevant. Please comment on the following specific points.

1. Do you support the killings of innocent people on the name of GOD? Islam is doing this sicnce its birth everywhere.

2. What is said in Koran about the KAFIR? Does it promote all kind of violence against KAFIR or non-belivers?

3. Nobody knows the exact form of the GOD. Your faith tell you that GOD is one & you have named him as Allah. The other communities also believe in GOD in some other forms. Then how it bothers Islam?

4. GOD has created everybody & given wisdom to everybody to live with. He never appointed your profet to order killing the people who don't beleive in him by your way. Killing the people (which are obviously created by GOD) on the name of the GOD is the biggest insult of the GOD.

5. You are saying that Isalm is for peace. But the history tells that peace has been lost wherever Isalm has entered. Islam has followed everywhere by sword & not by inspiration. Do not take you experiece in the last 28 years in Mumbai to verify this. You will have to study history of last many centuries with unbiased mindset.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:Is this the true religion?
by aceventura on Oct 06, 2007 09:52 AM   Permalink
Brother ,Who is fighting tell me.According to you all are same.First tell me who is fighting in India.Your mindset is so fixed.Dont forget the Bombay riots and Massacre in Gujarat? The Slogan in both of the above were to Loot and destroy muslim property and spare the Hindu property.Muslims have been pushed backward again and again, do you think its fair? The Middle Class and Lower Class Muslims are too busy making a living and supporting their families by what ever profession they are capable of.The more you hit the common man, the more you turn them your enemies. You will understand the pain if you loose any of your family member,so stop atrocities against any community and promote peace. This is the only path to prosperity. Discrimination will destroy the whole community.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Is this the true religion?
by Arjun Periyar on Oct 04, 2007 02:31 PM   Permalink
6. Do not try to glorify the Islamic rule in India. 80% of the country's Hindu population can never be proof of the tolerance of the Muslim invadors. It is existing because India was never completely ruled by the Muslim invadors. 20% of the Muslim population is the proof of the bloodshed & atrocities by the Muslim invadors. You may check your own history to find out how your ancestors were convetred to Muslim from Hindu religion.

7. Thousands of destroyed temples in the last many centuries (1100 A.D.) is the proof of tolerance of Isalm. If Islam is for peace then why it destroyed the civilization in India? There was a great hue & cry over the destruction of one mosque (Babri Mosque), then what should be done for the destruction of those thousands of temples which were not only the religious monuments but were also the symbols of our cultural heritage?

8. The world will become much more beautiful if Islam accepts tolerance & plural religious system existing the world. You should understand the you can love your religion without hating other's religion.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Is this the true religion?
by Ismail Sayyed on Oct 07, 2007 09:35 AM   Permalink
Ignorant hindu hates Islam, but their hindu guru, Shankaracharya have great respects for Islam. ITS TIME FOR EDUCATED HINDU BROTHER TO UNDERSTAND THE FACT FROM THEIR RELEGIOUS GURU.
Please refer to following video link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8zasuy9FBA


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Is this the true religion?
by Ismail Sayyed on Oct 07, 2007 09:37 AM   Permalink
Is it not the biggest terrorism to question the integrity of the other religion??? Whats terrorism for you? just killing people? then well mister there have been bigger acts of terrorism by many "fanatics"!!!!

Have some sense and speak man...try being tolerating and understand there is no religion that preaches killing people!

Do u even know that its clearly written in the Qur'an to respect all other religions?

And if some bunch of idiots are outthere it, then whats the difference between u and them?

I Am a muslim myself and i have friends and dear friends from all walks of faith. I dont think the way Osama does, i despise that and deny he is right, he is totally wrong. They are people who are doing such things in the name of religion, it is because they are not strong without masking their acts with religion.
Understand THAT.

Should we go ahead and blame sikhism for the killing in Canada?
Should the hindus be blamed for the 1984 riots?
No I as an educated person do not find it reasonable to blame an entire religion because of a few ignorant fools who committed crime.

Arent u educated and aware to think like a sane person?



   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Godhra panel asks for call details