Hello Manmohan Singh.... Hello Budhdhadeb Bhattacharya...are we living in 21st century?...are we under democracy?...what is this nonsense going on in the state , where the state Government has totally failed to take care of hundreads of innocent human lives?...what is the role of this Government ?...just to enjoy the mass killings from the sidelines and make the Central Govt. silent by pressure politics??????...where is the credibility of our favourite PM amd how can he keep silence on such a serious issue?...all these will never be answered and this pseudo industrialization process will continue in Bengal , and innocent lives will be taken by these 21st century modern reformers(CPM)...plzz dont make a mock of yourselves by leaving aside barren lands and acquiring fertile lands for industrialization...plzz dont take innocent lives...plzz relieve them of this nuissance for which they are not responsible...plzz
RE:democracy is dead...
by Sahadevan KK on Oct 29, 2007 12:33 PM Permalink
Corrupted leaders will sit in opposition throughout India as Mamta Banerjee
3 CPM cadres are assassinated by Trinamool Congress yesterday. Even then Modi supporters say here CPM are the killers. 3010 CPM cadres are killed for 30 years. Congress, RSS, TC, Naxalites etc. are the killers of CPM supporters there. Mamta is so frustrated. She got there what she has done before 30 years.
RE:democracy is dead...
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 12:35 PM Permalink
thanx for your kind information...why dont Budhdhababu prevent these killings??..is he credible enough to run this state?...silly communists...
RE:RE:democracy is dead...
by Subhabrata Roy on Oct 29, 2007 12:59 PM Permalink
Give me an option Biswarup.. Can you trust Mamata to run this state?? Its the worst dream come true for us.. Its no doubt that being in power for 30 years had made a huge section of leftists corrupt and arrogant (mostly in rural areas and even reflected in ration related agitations).. But hardly the TMC is an option.. Mamata had tremendous potential but somehow she with her whimsical attitude has succeded in removing the efficient and level headed ones like Sudip bandopadhyay, Nirbed Roy from her party..
RE:RE:democracy is dead...
by Ravi Nair on Oct 29, 2007 12:01 PM Permalink
It is a sad story of non-governance. What is Budhadeb doing thee ? Is he allowing people to rule themselves by carrying guns ? Declare a state of emergency in W.Bengal and deal with all political parties with an iron hand. Crush them to the core...We need a Sanjay Gandhi here...
RE:democracy is dead...
by Subhabrata Roy on Oct 29, 2007 12:46 PM Permalink
I hardly doubt if any of you stay in West Bengal.. That what is happenning in Nandigram is due to control of land.. However Left has to share its blame for not allowing to deploy paramilitary forces there on the first go and believing on the police forces.. But if you study the order of events then you will understand.. Earlier their demand was not to allow Industrialization on their land.. Fair enough.. Then this demand was accepted and Govt issued notices that there wont be any land acquisition.. But still the agitation continues.. Now newer demands keep scrolling up.. Hardly doubt if ordinary citizens of Nandigram are too happy.. They have become puppets in the hands of Mamata led TMC and LEFT on the other hand.. No way out for them..
RE:democracy is dead...
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 12:55 PM Permalink
industrialization on multicropping fertile lands??????...and that too leaving acres of barren lands in differnt places in Bengal???????...moreover by forcibly taking the lands from the peasents at the cost of their lives??...is there any rationality or far sightedness of Left in Bengal?????...Budhdhadeb has not only failed to control the anarchy , but is shameless enough to burden the opposition of these incidents...if Govt had the intention to check the situation , they could have easily done it...in this way , he himself is digging his own grave , although that would be a much welcome result for people in Bengal...lastly , the entire nation knows what is going on in bengal...Plzz leave the rabbit mentality...come out of your burrough and you will find that you are naked and everyone is laughing at you...so plzz be sensible...
RE:democracy is dead...
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 01:03 PM Permalink
very well mentioned in the previous post Subhabrata babu...Mamata has killed herself...I agree with you...but does that mean that we will support these killers... dont you think that we are doing injustice to our future generation...what will we teach them?... we need an immediate central intervention and kick these communists out from power...we need a substantial period of President's rule in the state...let the state people realise , what should be their next option then...not going by substituting one poison for another , i think that would be a better option...
RE:democracy is dead...
by Kaushik Basu on Oct 29, 2007 01:06 PM Permalink
But do the ppl really get a chance to elect?? isnt it a very well established fact that votes r won by rigging...wen was the last time we had something called "fair election" in bengal?
RE:RE:democracy is dead...
by Subhabrata Roy on Oct 29, 2007 01:16 PM Permalink
Last time elections held in Bengal there was enough security.. But what was the result.. In 2001 assemble elections when exit polls did show that mamata and left will be at par.. Mamata showed victory signs and said we had fair elections.. But when results showed up she reversed her statement accusing the govt of rigging.. The vote share betwwen the TMC and congress has come to the advantage of CPM but then again is this Buddha's fault.. I am sure Biswarup will like to endorse this view as he is too intelligent.. But unfortunately we who are not so intelligent like him can't
RE:RE:democracy is dead...
by Subhabrata Roy on Oct 29, 2007 01:09 PM Permalink
Biswarup its not a question of opposition for the sake of opposition which you are resorting to. If you believe that WB needs anarchy and restlessness and has that capability to turn away investments.. that you must be TOO WISE.. Perhaps you are of the old communist ideology that existed in WB earlier that investors will follow what the govt says and have to invest where they like.. My dear learned friend thats not the case.. If you dont be investment friendly then they will move to some other state.. MP, Orissa, Jharkhand is waiting with open arms.. When Budhha is trying to bring investments in this state then people like you are trying to disrupt that off.. But strangely your voice remains mum when same investments take place in multicropped lands in Orissa, Gujrat, etc
RE:democracy is dead...
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
DON'T KILL INNOCENT PEOPLE AND RESORT TO PURE POLITICS YOU SHAMELESS FELLOWS...ONLY THEN YOU CAN DO JUSTICE TO YOURSELVES...
RE:democracy is dead...
by deepak bhatia on Oct 29, 2007 12:15 PM Permalink
Absolutely right. This govt has become the puppet of Communists, who at one hand support them and immediately twist the arm. The Central govt does say even 'ouch'. This is the democracy by the politicians, for the politicians and with the politicians. Nobody bothers about the very people who send them to rule the country. And you can's except anything from communists. They are just good for nothing. They can't withstand the opposition. If you speak against them or their policies, they will shut you up with a bullet in your head. That's what is going on in W.Bengal. Do the people of W.Bengal listening and understanding the policies of their rulers?
