Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by keshav kumar on Oct 23, 2007 04:48 AM   Permalink | Hide replies

PM MMS has not felt the insult to Pranab Mukherjee when Russian FM refused to meet him.The PM does not accept the views of scientific community who know that the talk of power generation is ridiculous. If PM knows every thing then why did he go for cure to AIIMS.He should have cured himself on his own since he knows better than doctors as he wants every body to believe.Fact is that he is history blind and his pushing the deal really amounts to an act of treason since it harms the security of India as US will get control of our Nuke power. If the PM can list a single benefit for India in the deal then why doesn't he do it.
India has a large community of scientists and engineers.Even President Kalam pointed out that the deal was not in India's interest. Mrs.Sonia Gandhi is not an engineer or scientist and how can she talk of electric power generation when she has no understanding of it.
In 1992,MMS immensely harmed India's defence capablity when he unwisely and blindly abrogated the Rupee trade agreement with USSR/Russia.It all shows that the PM MMS is not the right person to be the PM of India when he does things to harm India's basic security and has a track record of harming India's security.
The deal as it is in the present shape it is anti-India, needs to be thrown out into a dustbin.
Our constitution needs to be amended so that such deal cannot be entered into without the approval of the Parliament.The present situation is making the PM a dictator. How is it democrati

    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by Anil Khare on Oct 23, 2007 05:48 AM   Permalink
Keshav, you are absolutely right. Truth is always bitter to certain persons, ignore your critics.

IAEA representative Dr. El-Bashir (from Syria???) came ahead of time to inspect India's Nuclear Facilities. This itself shows hidden intentions behind this deal. I doubt even USA is aware of many things behind this.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by jogarao munjuluri on Oct 23, 2007 06:50 AM   Permalink
All of us including MMS forget that PVN Rao then PM managed the political part of 1991 economic reforms and credit shd therefore go to PVN and not to MMS. Obvoiusly present political manager ( UPA Cp Sonia) neither has the capability nor sincerity to back up any national issue like deal or Ramsethu except her family. JUst because you entered the deal without taking people into confidence (MMS had all along was telling Parliament and Public " wait for for the fonal draft before opininating)and now he is blackmailing all the political class with take it or take my headdefacto. It is clear cheating of public by MMS.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by sandeep lobo on Oct 23, 2007 06:38 AM   Permalink
u r an a**, without brain, u better judge ur openion on what u have acieved in ur life till now....I am sure not much......had u, u wouldn't have vomited this uncommon nonsense

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by ishpreet walia on Oct 23, 2007 05:13 AM   Permalink
R u nuts ... A**hole ...u calling PM dictator ... LMAO ... i thnk u r the first one who is saying tht ... i thnk he is one who in 1990 helped inidan economy from crises and moreover what do u knw abt the deal ... every deal will have its pros and cons ... Its just a simple tradeoff ... to get sumthng you have to lose sumthng ... what is important Indian security or energy needs for the ppl who r dieing ... Stop barking for no reason and start thinking out of the box

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by NOOR DANISH on Oct 23, 2007 06:35 AM   Permalink
PM is trying to be dictator of india. he is trying to sell india to western power. stop him and also congres for this.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by Sahadevan KK on Oct 23, 2007 01:25 PM   Permalink
Left rejects govt plea on IAEA talks, because Left is not ready to eat biryani and forget Indian people; not ready to take ministership and implement anti-people policy; not ready to take money and say "yes sir, yes sir."


   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by nalini menon on Oct 23, 2007 05:21 AM   Permalink
Sorry to differ.Indian communists have always sided with the interests of International Communism.Their loyalty was never with our Country. Take the example of 1942.They were fighting against the British along with the Congress for the Country's independence.But suddenly,Hitler attacked Russia and then Russia, the Communist fatherland joined Britain.Immdtly the Indian Communists withdrew from the Independence struggle, their arrested leaders were released and the rest is history.
Come to 1962.Chinese aggression against the unsuspecting Nehru.The Communists were not on India's side. Their loyalty to the Movement is beyond national boundaries. The writing on the wall is clear.China is going to be the biggest power, in another decade's time.Then they will try to overrun all others in Asia. but USA in their own selfinterest-not out of love for India- wants somebody like India to be able to resist the Chinese and prevent their becoming the World No 1. So, that is why America is willing to develop India's nuclear capability without insisting on our signing the Nuclear Non-proliferation agreement.This policy will change if a Democratic Party President rules USA.Hence the urgency to push thro the deal.Man MohanSingh is right.Let us understand these realities and mobilise support for him.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:N-deal has nothing for India except disaster
by KrishnaPrasad Bhat on Oct 23, 2007 05:20 AM   Permalink
Excellent. Looks like you are from the camp which believes that RAHUL GANDHI is right person for PM's seat. Good. Keep on day dreaming.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Analysis: The real deal on the N-deal