Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Deal or No Deal
by Ramasubramaniam Iyer on Oct 24, 2007 11:26 PM   Permalink | Hide replies

1. Our Honorable PM should understand he is a PM not the king of this country that when he signs a deal everyone accepts it.
2. Did our PM take allies/commies into confidence before signing this deal?
3. Let us do a thorough analysis of what are our pros/cons before signing this deal and if the commies have a valid point address them rather than brush it under the carpet.
4. On the other hand the commies need to understand that just for the sake of opposing US dont opposse. Think objectively if this deal will help our country and put forth any valid points of concern you have.
5. This is democracy guys. There are reasons why a PM doesnt have absolute power.
6. From My point of view lets go ahead with this deal, making nuclear bombs will not feed our hungry population and lets not go the Russia way on that.
7. While we are going ahead with this deal lets ensure our scientists get exposure to latest technologies and let them come up with inventions/innovations of their own on alternative sources of energy so that even if we walk out of the deal at a later stage we know we have an alternative which is viable and sustainable

    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:Deal or No Deal
by Raj on Oct 28, 2007 02:33 PM   Permalink
1... It is the prerogative of the Government of the day to take policy decisions, all over the world.
2.. All the cabinet had agreed that they trust Manmohan Singh on the N-Deal. Only after this authorisation did Manmohan sign the deal. Before this deal was signed various objections to it, like reprocessing rights, Fuel supply were taken care of.
3...Commies are NOT really opposing this deal. What they are opposing is anything that India does with USA and the West. They are even objecting to outsourcing, military tie ups, and anything which threatens China, and anything which will help India become a Superpower.
4...Its only the commies who are really against the USA as they have to answer their Masters in China. It has been found out in a recent survey that max. number of Indians like USA and wants to have a good relationship with it. Iran and China on the contrary have never supported India on any thing, be it UNSC permanent membership or on Kashmir.
5.....Democracy doesnt mean that the Government has to take permission from the opposition for any policy decisions, as opposition will always oppose to anything that government does, specially in India.
6...This deal is for power generation only and this deaol will free India to use its scarce uranium stocks to build weapons.
7....This deal will take India out of Isolation and will provide our scientists and Engineers to master new technology, besides ofcourse generating thousands of jobs for Indians and giving a fillip

   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Analysis: The real deal on the N-deal