IQBAL WROTE SARE JAHN SE ACHA AS A TEEN AGER IN SCHOOL IN 1910 'S LATER IN1930 'S WHEN HE DEVELOPED VIRUS OF 2 NATION THEORY . HE WROTE MUSLIM HAIN HUM MHAZAB HAIN SARA JAHN HAMARA .HE IS THE PERSON WHO CLOTHED 2 NATION THEORY IN IDEOLOGY EVEN BEFORE JINNAH . HE DIED IN 1938 BEFORE MUSLIM LEAGUE ADOPTED PAKISTAN RESOLUTION IN 1941 IN LAHORE . HE CERTAINLY DID NOT WRITE SARE JAHN SE ACHA PAKISTAN HAMARA ALL HIS WRITINGS ARE FUNDAMENTLY ISLAMIC ESPOUSING 2 NATION THEORY ,BUT MOST INDIANS THINK HE WAS ANOTHER BANKIM CHANDRA CHATTERJI HE IS THE NATIONAL POET OF PAKISTAN I DO NOT BLAME TARUN AS HE LIVES IN GHETTO OF HINDI JOURNALISM WHERE THERE IS HARDLY ANY ORIGINAL RESEARCH AND QUERY. MOST OF THE PEOPLE IN POWER OR IN OPPOSITION DO NOT THINK BEYOND PERMUTATION AND COMBINATION OF CASTE POLITICS .PICK UP ANY INDIAN NEWSPAPER OR MAGAZINE YOU READ ABOUT GOWDA. LALU. MAYAWATI OR KANGRESS WALAS SINGING PEANS TO SONIA GANDHI AND THAT SARDAR LOOKING MORE LACK LUSTER AND IRRELEVANT THERE ARE NO NATIONAL ISSUES OTHER THAN IN POSTS HERE WHILE IN SCHOOL IN PRESENT PAKISTAN BEFORE 1947 WE USED TO SING HIS POEM LAB PER ATI HAE BAN KAR YEH TAMAMN MERI YAA KHUDAI TERE DUM SE MERE NAM SE DUNIYA MAIN UJALA HO JAYE AS MORNING PRAYER I
RE:CONFUSION ABOUR IQBAL'S POEMS
by on Nov 07, 2007 03:21 PM Permalink
Are Alamma Iqbal (poet - 2nation theory) and Mohd. Iqbal (poet - Sare Jahan Se Achcha) two different persons or the same person?
RE:CONFUSION ABOUR IQBAL'S POEMS
by Dipak Bose on Nov 07, 2007 03:55 PM Permalink
Same Person. Allama is a honorary name just like we say Chacha Nehru or Bapu Gandhi.
RE:CONFUSION ABOUR IQBAL'S POEMS
by s k on Nov 07, 2007 02:14 AM Permalink
you said the same thing what tarun said - that iqbal is a fundamentalist. why are you going bonkers over him?
RE:CONFUSION ABOUR IQBAL'S POEMS
by hanek singh on Nov 09, 2007 12:46 AM Permalink
sk putr, yeh sab teri iqal se upar ki baat ihi tu lagta hai bahut kuch pagal hai thara soch samajh kar piya kar teri itni capacity nahin hai beta ji ke ek khalsa se panga leapna nam tu likh deta
