Well Done Shabnam
by zaheen usmani on May 29, 2007 07:32 AM Permalink | Hide replies

Dear Shabnam you have done a great job after envovlving youself in the affairs of Gujrat,It is duty of all the intelectullas and socialist and humanright activist to expose the cummunal ddeds of gujrat government,only Teesta Harsh mander can not do all the works.

Forward | 'Report abuse' disabled by moderator

RE:Well Done Shabnam
by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay on May 29, 2007 07:41 AM Permalink

When islamism, Jihadism is sweeping the Islamic world, specially the neighborhood of India and now expanded to India, prey tell us:

1. How many write ups, symposiums, discussions she organized on these?

2. does she and those like her, understand that Indian Islam is under attack from deobondi, Wahabi polemic?

People like have lectured too long, never showed any concern for democracy, secularism, or minority rights in Kashmir, Bangladesh, Pakistan.

So, whatever had to happen has happened. THEY HAVE NO ONLY EXPOSE THEMELVES AS JIHdi, THEY HAVE DONE INCALCULABLE DAMAGE TO REAL SECULARISM.

NOW SECULARISM HAS BECOME A JOKE IN INDIA. RECISELY BECAuse people like her.

Forward | Report abuse

RE:Well Done Shabnam
by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay on May 29, 2007 07:36 AM Permalink

Why doesn't Shabnam preach human rights, democracy, secularism, rights of minority in Kashmir Valley, Bangladesh, Pakistan and 55 Islamic nations where minorities are second class citizen?

hehe..who is fooling whom? My friend, these people by their sheer double standard have achieved two things:

1. Legitimized Modi.
2. Communalized the whole thing.

I am a secular p[erson who believes in equal rights of every Indian.

Forward | Report abuse

RE:Well Done Shabnam
by Mike Jordan on May 29, 2007 07:54 AM Permalink
Bhaskar, why dont you go and preach Islamic countries, if you are so concerned about human rights in other countries than your own country.

Forward | Report abuse

RE:RE:Well Done Shabnam
by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay on May 29, 2007 08:04 AM Permalink

IF MUSLIMS ARE UNABLE TO ENSURE HUMAN RIGHTS IN ISLAMIC COUNTRIES, THEIR CONCERN FOR HUMAN RIGHTS IN COUNTRIES WHERE THEY ARE MINORITY BECOMES HOLLOW.

IT WORKS BOTH WAYS. PEOPLE ARE NOT FOOL. AT LEAST IN THIS AGE OF CONNECTIVITY.

POPE HAS ALREADY ASKED FOR RECIPROCACITY IN ISLAMIC COUNTRIES.

Forward | Report abuse