this is crazy
by Maya CD on May 16, 2007 06:28 PM Permalink | Hide replies

I am sorry and i refuse to beleive a white mans history book.

when the people died they died for a belief and not for india as there was no country as such.

anyway most of william darylymple book is crap(which is what your article is based upon)

Forward | Report abuse

Message deleted by moderator

RE:this is crazy
by mohammed ahmed on May 17, 2007 12:09 PM Permalink
Dear Freind,

You will not read Communist History(Irfan Habeeb),

you will not read secular history(Nehru),

you will not read Muslim history (Sir Syed ahmed),

and also not this English history......

and then you are left with only two options....

either Believe on your own imaginations.... or the RSS fabrications.

and these two are one and the same.....

both will make you IGNORANT.... as well as .... ARROGANT.

May Allah save you......

Forward | Report abuse

Re: RE:this is crazy
by Rahul Gupta on Jun 08, 2009 10:46 AM Permalink
Mohammed not only was Tansen converted even you were converted. One of the converters put a Pistol in your Great Grand Pa's small black back hole and he converted and started chanting Allah hu Akbar.

Forward | Report abuse

Message deleted by moderator

RE:this is crazy
by mahesh arjundas kalra on May 17, 2007 02:03 PM Permalink
My dear dear friend,

History is not secular or communal

the writers are the pink eyed ones

RSS is not the only imaginative force

there are also some communist and secular ones

If Akbar was liberal why was Tansen converted

It's in the eyes of the historian perverted

Islam ruled by the sword is a fact undeniable

Whether you shout,cry it is still not a fable

We should see History as our very story

Clean of distortions or ready to be sorry

For our ancestors lived in a very different age

When all ideologies were still in an embryonic stage !!!

So an Akbar or an Aurangzeb did not care

How many infidels fell to their swords naked stare

Woh Zamana kucch aur thha

Yeh Zamana kucch aur hai

Kyon ladna yaaron

Jab marnewale tab bhi hum the

Aur aaj bhi hum hai

Dr.Mahesh Kalra

Forward | Report abuse

RE:RE:this is crazy
by mohammed sahim ahmed on May 17, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink

Dr. Saheb

Respectfully, i would add that,

Generally, poetry is good to ears but may not tell the TRUTH.

Forward | Report abuse

RE:this is crazy
by mahesh arjundas kalra on May 18, 2007 01:13 PM Permalink
You are right my friend. Let's not fight in our

country if at all we want to honour the legacy of 1857. Let's forget the past grievances if we want a brighter future. Forget fizzull ladayii.

Regards

Dr.Mahesh A. Kalra

P.S. Atleast you agree the poem was good.

Thanx for the compliment although left-handed

Forward | Report abuse