It is true that Industrialisation in WestBengal needs lots ofincentives. But Why Tata. It can be seen tht th same Tata Motors pricng its Indica in Pune (Mahrahtra) at a price not less than 4 lacs, even after crosing the breadk even part. Then how are they going to give thesamecar at 1 lac Rupees. It is all eye wash. It can be seen that In Pune Tata motors have monopolised their industry and int eheindustry every one know that they do not make the payment not less than 45 days. They run the industry on others' monye. Do they need the support in giving sengur land. The same can be talked about Nandigram. Some thing is behin the ice. prabu
RE:tata &Indica&Budadeb
by Jayanta on Mar 22, 2007 11:53 AM Permalink
This is the problem. We don't think what we should. What's harm in it if someone wants to give a car in 1.0L or 1.5L ! Does it pinching you! All are expert and understand business better than Tata or Reliance!
RE:tata &Indica&Budadeb
by prabirbaran sarkar on Mar 22, 2007 11:58 AM Permalink
Yes, when Maruty udyug was setting up their manufactureing unit they promished to sell car at 45000/- each car,as it would a small family car. Tata also doing the same thing to get facilities as maximum as possible. We know that an Auto ricksaw is sold now at 1 lakh rupees. Why state goverments are so eager to give so many things free from public money to Tata? And that too innocent farmers who do not know many things and being murdered . Is it a justification? P.B.S
RE:RE:tata &Indica&Budadeb
by A chackraborty on Mar 22, 2007 12:13 PM Permalink
the stae government has go crores of rupees for the upcoming 2009 general elections. theywant to build up a large fund of Rs 1,00,000 crores by selling `1,00,000 acres of farmers land to disreputed industrialists like SALEM of indonesia so that they can increase their strength from 60 to 150 in 2009. in Rajarhat they have given the farmers Rs 5. lakhs per acre and are selling to IT companiea at 300 lakhs per acre. Where is all the rest of the money going. why is the state govt selling land when the farmers could directly negotiate with the industrialist? that is because they want a big cut of the profit from the induatrialist.
RE:RE:tata &Indica&Budadeb
by Jayanta on Mar 22, 2007 12:09 PM Permalink
Nobody does business spending money from their own pocket!We need to see in bigger perspective. Tata is investing in WB after change in vision of Govt. But once again we in Bengal are so intelligent and inteect, that we have started opposing the whole process. In any work in INDIA, nothing goes right. Still if 70% happens sacrificing 30%, that's also a great achievement. So,please think big, think fast and think differently.
