Everyone is talking about dicussion between common people of nandigram and Govt. But the fact is that, before anything had been initiated by Govt. about land accusition, based on rumours, some people destroy one police jeep and CPM party office. Also the panchyat bhawan was attacked. Then all the local CPIM supporters (around 3000) fled from the area and took shelter in Khejuri. 5 CPIM supporters were brutally killed and two CPIM women supporters were raped by the opponents. After that no police were allowed to enter in nandigram. 6 all party meetings were held there for next 2 and half months and CM repeatedly told in the media that without the consent of Nandigram people no land accusition will take place. But still the oponents were not allowing the police and the ran away CPM local supporters to enter into the area. Then some local CPM leaders created pressure on CM for the Police action without informing that what could be the consequences. And few Police officers and the hooligans of CPM party that day started firing on the mob when they were attacked by a large gang of people where women and children were placed in front to stop the police. The oppositions are very happy about the things that had happened in Nandigram. Now everywhere they are raising protest against land accusition, even in puruliya or bankura where lands are not fertile. These oppositions are creating a blockade between the Govt and the common people and that's why in every case communication gaps and rumours have started taking place. Also the Govt. is not doing much about this. Don't forget that CM didn't allowed the police to take any strong measures in Govindapur Rail colony where Kolkata High Court had given order to drive out the people who occupied the land of Railway ministry illegaly. Opponent opposed this and started protesting the verdict and rail refused to give any compensession for that. Then WB Govt. arranged a land for those people and discussed the matter with opposition and the matter was amicably solved and those people were rehabilitated in the new area. But in Nandigram opposition played foul and they made the situation worse. They stopped all type of discussion with the Govt and always opposed them. Now they are very happy for this unfortunate and brutal killings. They are now getting huge support for the act.
RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Uttamkumar on Mar 23, 2007 09:18 AM Permalink
This guy and his family fled from Bangladesh When Bangladesh was fighting against Pakistan for freedom. Now they criticize India and Indians.
Not only that these guys have direct/indirect link to terrorists coming to West Bengal/India and shelter them providing ration card and voter ID.
These guys are most opportunists, and hypocrites.
Indian Govt must act promptly to eliminate this type of criminals, otherwise West Bengal is going to be another Kashmir in very near future.
RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Arya Gupta on Mar 22, 2007 02:17 PM Permalink
Stop reading Aajkaal and Ganshakti and try to find out facts yourself.
RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Suman Chattopadhyay on Mar 22, 2007 09:29 PM Permalink
So I can also suggest you to stop reading Bartaman also. Finding facts means what? Do you think that around 3000 CPIM supportes are not forced to leave their land and homes from nandigram 3 months ago. I am following the news from the first week of January itself. And I read different newspapers also (ofcourse not Ganashakti). Do you say that the way Govindapur Rail colony people were rehabilitated is wrong? I raised that issue because if the opposition creates the environment then this CM at least have the desire to talk and find a solution which is acceptable to all. But here opposition created the situation like that way so that no dialog could take place and rumours about land accusition can easily be spread. They are following the Path of Keshpur. They know if this type of massacre happens then most of the people will go against the Govt. Whether it SEZ or no SEZ, this thing bound to happen. Because it is a preplanned thing to create chaos and forcefully drive the ruling party off from their strong hold. Otherwise if it is related to SEZ only then why after CM's declaration no land accusition will take place without the consent of Nandigram people, no opposition parties took the initiative to start the dialog and solve the issue amicably. Only fact is that then this issue would not hit the headlines. This is not a SEZ related issue. This is the same old story where the hooligans of both the ruling and opposition parties clashed to get control of the Nandigram area and few innocent people (whether they are CPIM supporters or opposition members) got killed and their lives are ruined.
RE:RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Suman Chattopadhyay on Mar 22, 2007 09:44 PM Permalink
And one more fact I want to add and that is CPIM will not want to create this type of problem unless they are bound by the oppostion parties to do so. Becasue they know as they are the ruling parties if such situation occurs then it will go against the ruling party every time and opposition will get the sympathy. But like in Keshpur, here in Nandigram also opposition got the success to drag CPIM down into this situation. Like in Keshpur, naxalites are also helping TMC in Nandigram. Also they are getting help from so called nationalist (or communal) parties like Jamat E Ulema E Hind and BJP. Somebody also compares the situation with Gujrat and Jalianwalabag. This brutal killing of Nadigram definitily should be condemned but it should not be compared with the Gujrat mass killing or Jalianwalabagh. Those were more severe acts. Also will someone highlight why like in Keshpur only innocent poor people lost their lives not any of the so called brave and rebel leaders of opposition parties were unhurt? Were they taking shelter behind the poor women and children?
RE:RE:RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by mariappan on Mar 23, 2007 01:09 PM Permalink
No fool will like to agitate if land was not the issue, everyone here seems to know what buddhadeb wanted to do but the truth is nandigram erupted only, i repeat only after a Government order for acquistion of land in nandigram was issued by the haldia development authorities, it is another matter that buddhadeb went on record saying the concerned department had no authority to issue such an order. If Buddhadeb is clear in his conscience, instead of repeating the same lie a thousand times "No land will be acquired in nandigram" the simple fact will be to issue another Government order withdrawing the earlier order issued by the haldia development authority. Why is he not doing that. Finally Mr.Suman, anything the communists do is perfectly right but not what gujarat does. At least in gujarat, Modi didnt allow his policemen to kill mercilessly women and children, at most the gujarat policemen can be charged with not taking action, but they didnt kill anyone deliberately as in nandigram. So stop comparing with gujarat.
RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Suman Chattopadhyay on Apr 15, 2007 12:43 AM Permalink
Definately I am not comparing Nandigram with Gujrat where more than 1000 (if not more)innocent people have lost their lives and many others lost their livelyhood. Police were not taking actions but few rapes were done by them in Gujrat. Actually to kill 1000 odd people or rape innocent muslim women, Modi's cadres are undoubtedly best in India. So why should I compare Nandigram with Gujrat?
And for your information, Mr. Buddhadev was not lying. He already declared officially that no land acquisition will take place in Nandigram but still 3000 of CPM supporters along with their family members are not allowed to enter into their houses (most of those houses are already burnt off and looted by the so called peace loving rebels in Nandigram). No regrets for those poor people who were killed by the Nandigrams peace loving rebels. No regrets for a Police officer Sadhu chatterje brutally killed by the Nandigram rebels (as because they are police and CPM not humans). No police and administrative persons are allowed to enter into Nandigram. If after all this somebody says that Budhhadev is lying 1000 times then I should say please don't write anything out here in rediff. Instead you go and join either Modi or Mamta's cadre party and start creating chaos. This way only you people can serve your country better and no matter how many (may be in lacks or crores) innocent people will be killed for that.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by Suman Chattopadhyay on Mar 22, 2007 09:47 PM Permalink
Please read "will someone highlight why like in Keshpur only innocent poor people lost their lives and not any of the so called brave and rebel leaders of opposition parties were hurt?"
RE:RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by later gupta on Mar 23, 2007 06:36 AM Permalink
All know, left parties'leader follows ideology of European debris ! Its misfit in India, which is basically a spiritually based land, protected many a times by the spiritual power. Its not necessary for anyone to agree to it becase blinds disagree to the existence of SUN! "Man may come,and man may go ,but I go on forever" Tennyson said it .That is the spirit of Indian soil. Many present has become 'THE PAST' Why quarrel? SIT DOWN AND TRY TO UNDERSTAND 'WHY INDIA IS GREAT' NO IDEOLOGY /RELIGION /DOCTRINS CAN MATCH INDIAN PHILOSOPHY, AND THATS WHY TODAY 'SWAMI VIVEKANANDA' IS ONE OF THE TEN GREATS WHO HAVE SET THE DESTINY OF PRESENT AMERICA(please check up your knowledge) INDIAN PHILOSOPHY DEALS TOTALLY- FROM EMERGENCE OF SOUL TO MERGING OF THE SOUL TO ITS SOURCE! IT DEALS WITH PARENTS, BIRTH, THE RITES TO DO, THE EDUCATION , THE SOCIETY, THE EVILS/ GOODS OF SOCIETY,THE METHODS OF DEALING EVILS, THE PURPOSE OF IT, THE AIM OF A HUMAN BIRTH,THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN AN ANIMAL AND A MAN,HOW A MAN BE A MAN , FOOD -THE NATURE OF FOOD TO ACHIEVE GOALS, THE WHAT NOTS , CONTAINS EVERYTHING UNLIKE THE IDEOLOGIES OF THE OTHERS WHO DEALIN PART. BASICALLY, THE PHILOSOPHY THAT WAS WIDELY FOLLOWED IN INDIA AT A TIME WHEN MECAULAY'S EDUCATION SYSTEM(BRITISH)WAS NOT YET INTRODUCED, NOW VERY SELDOM PRACTICED(courtsey CONGRESS REGIME)AND WIDELY ACCEPTED BY THE ONLOOKING WORLD OF OUTSIDE INDIA DEALS WITH EQUALITY OF EVRYBODY (NOT IN EATING, OR MATING OR MONEY) IN RESPECT OF STATUS(ORIGIN OF BEING)--THE SOUL! ONE WOULD NOT SCORN AT ANOTHER!EVERYONE IS RESPECTFUL MAY HE BE A BEGGAR OR A KING!(cant be discussed in details!) OUTSIDE EQUALITY IS NO EQUALITY, MENTALWQUALITY IS SOME EQUALITY!COMPLETE EQUALITY IS ACCEPTING THE OTHER AS SAME AS ONESELF BUT THAT WILL NOT BE REFLECTED IN OUTWARD ONENES IN EATING OR MATING.All these are said to impress that a larger section of people are so MESMERISED entities, running too much after material world, (though material needs also are to be caterd for)that the goal of life is lost! There is no king today, the parliament has taken over in BRITISH STYLE(as if that can do good!We see more the number more the chaos. Today there is shortage of UNBIASEWD WISE MEN!IT STARTED FROM THE DAYS OF M K GANDHI(so Subhas had to go!) So long as the Government is TRULY WISE people have to suffer.In democracy, people get a government as they are! So if people adopt WISER MEANS THEY WILL GET A SATISFYING GOVERNMENT. HOW to become wise? Today, everyone knows ' A total management is always the best!" WHY NOT in people's lives too? INDIAN PHILOSOPHY ONLY CAN PROVIDE THE MEANS OF ACHIEVING IT! NO OTHER ISMS OFANY PLACE IN THE WORLD! THE SOONER THE INTELLIGENTIA UNDERSTANSIT THE BETTER!
RE:RE:Budhha Against Faremrs and Poor
by TSN Xumar on Mar 23, 2007 09:52 AM Permalink
Arya - u r a Maoist - Maoist are dogs - and they need to be shot -
