Tell me one thing....how many people would be employed in a car factory?? What will happen to the farmers whose land are gone ? Will they find employment ? Tata requires an area 6 times that of maruti's Gurgao plant with 6 times more land ... What will happen in the rest of the land...May be used as real estate for the tata's... What did Salim Group did in indonesia?? It finished the indonesian communists and is under prosecution there , and here communists are supporting him !!!.....Now he wants to open a chemical hub in nandigram....Is it known that chemical hubs are banned in European Countries the so called "developed nations". Sulphuric acid is so toxic it is not produced by any of the developed countries but in haldia it is only made....Is it sufficient or I need to write more...I can write a few more pages if u insist....
RE:Read the facts ....
by allen on Mar 19, 2007 05:30 PM Permalink
deep talukdar... An automobile Unit is highly manpower itensive unlike process industries... It comes along wid a big pack of anciliaries ..which again generate huge employment.. a rough estimate wud b like ...to roll our 5 lac vehicles a year ... one wud require at least ten thousand ppl working frm all front... PLZ NOTE ..MARUTI doesnt hv a closed complex of ancilliaries which TATA's are planning...if u put all d ancilliaries into account ..MARUTI has more dan double ...wat TATA wud get... U MAY B IGNORANT ...CONSULT A AUTO EXPERT...
RE:[object]
by abby Das on Mar 26, 2007 06:07 PM Permalink
One more thing i must say.generating employment for 8000 - 10,000(at most) the tatas are taking 997 acres of multicropped land.Do you have any idea how many people they would be making unemployed?
RE:Read the facts ....
by abby Das on Mar 26, 2007 06:05 PM Permalink
well,Allen,I have a relative who works for Hyundai.(I hope you would consider as an expert). To produce 5 lacs vehicle a year one would require not more than 8,000 wrokers(Your estimation was wrong in the very first place).Secondly,what ancillery units are you talking about exactly?Have the Tatas cleared mentioned the details anywhere?Have they quantifiesd the number of people exactly who would be getting jobs in those industries?How much land exactly(in quantitaive terms) would they erquire for each ancillery units?
If you have these answers please clarify them first .Or else admit that you are ignorent too.
