Godhra incident can not be compared with Nandigram incident. In Godhra no one killed others by hiding behind the police and using police's ammunition. And to say the least, don't compare Gujrat, the best administered, industrialized, most affluent and most tax-paying state of the country with West-Bengal the corrupt state run by communists with the help of the Cadre-goons, with closed industries and lacking all kind of infrastructure.
In the name of giving jobs to "our boys (read CPM cadres)", Nilotpal very conveniently forgot about eating the jobs of the poor farmers!! "Our boys" could have got job as well in a chemical hub built on barren-land instead of fartile land of Nandigram.
RE:Nilotpal Basu's explanation
by Sumit Mukherjee on Mar 19, 2007 05:55 PM Permalink
Dear Mr Basu,
It is unfortunate that there are so many people killed at nandigram. You people need space to built up factories. It is my suggestion to acquire land of the closed factories all over west bengal , specially HIDE Road , which is much nearer to kolkata. And also acquire the non culivated land for industrilization purpose
RE:Nilotpal Basu's explanation
by Shalini Banerjee on Mar 19, 2007 05:10 PM Permalink
Well Said Mr. Ghoshal, but how did Gujarat become a industrialized state? And one more thing...even if the government now tries to acquire barren land in W.B, the same would not be allowed. Just look at the time it takes to clear up 4-5 houses in the Anwar Shah - Bypass connector to make a road which would benfit lakhs of people....in W.B there is a policy called the "Uddhar Plocy"....everyone is sort of doing a favor by doing his job....talk to a autowala, a bus conductor, a shop owner, a police constable....they act like almighty god....so when u have so many gods on earth...even the almighty can not help this state...it is not abou CPIM or Trinamool....it is about the Bengali race which has degenrated.
RE:RE:Nilotpal Basu's explanation
by KALYAN MITRA on Mar 19, 2007 05:41 PM Permalink
Shalini - Donot degrade yourself as I feel you too a bengali...and bengali outside bengal is not degraded.
I absolutely agree with you...Bengalis outside W.B are a different breed....they I think are the original bengalis....look at the successfull bengali youth today....how many r from W.B>
RE:RE:RE:RE:Nilotpal Basu's explanation
by KALYAN MITRA on Mar 19, 2007 05:54 PM Permalink
Shalini - Even there are lakhs of Bengalis in WB who are too good and not degraded..problem is CPM.
RE:RE:Nilotpal Basu's explanation
by Jayanto Roy on Mar 19, 2007 05:36 PM Permalink
Well said. Very apt. Indeed it is the Bengali race which has degenrated & it pains me terribily in saying this as I too am a bengali.
