Can the CM be isolated from the CPIM as a hard core political outfit that resorts to violence as propagated by the Marxian dialectics being the the only means central to capturing political power? Political power flows out of the barrel of the gun in the core philosophy of any communists party. On this score Stalin was deadlier than Hitler. What has happened therefore in Nandigram is not new in the CPIM records of violence perpetrated in West Bengal. But what Indians as a whole should decry is the clandenstine Congress support as a quid pro quo for its own survival. The CPIM is only exacting its pound of flesh. BD and Mira as his cohabitor NEED BOTH BE HANGED BY NATA MULLICK THE HANGMAN WHOM MIRA SHOWCASED ON PUBLIC ROSTRUMS IN DISGUSTING TASTES THAT PROVED SHE LACKED CULTURE. GR Sagar
RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by ABC XYZ on Mar 18, 2007 11:56 AM Permalink
Shut up and go to sleep. You have no idea what you are talking about. Who do you want as next CM? Maa Mamata. She'll feed with you dudhbhat...
RE:RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by ABC XYZ on Mar 18, 2007 12:06 PM Permalink
I'm no cadre mister. You are a psuedo-intellectual, who has no iota of brain. I never said I support CPM of Jyoti Basu generation. I'm in full support of Buddhadeb and his initiative. If you cannot see what he's trying to do being Bengal at par with rest of India, then you're nuts. The only reason can be because you're a sick fan of Maa Mamata.
RE:RE:RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by sanjay choudhry on Mar 18, 2007 12:21 PM Permalink
Dear ABC:
You are missing the most crucial point. Why cannot Salem group buy the land from farmers directly by paying market price that is agreeable to both Salem and farmers?
This has been allowed by Narendra Bhai in Gujarat. Dozens of SEZs have been set up there with aboslutely no peasant unrest as the corporates have paid very good price for the land on the coastline and the farmers are very happy with the deal.
The Bengal govt. is trying to buy land cheap and sell it to Salem Group at five times the rate it paid to farmers. It is trying to make indecent profit from the deal, and hence the unrest and farmers feeling cheated.
Leave the buying and selling to market forces and Bengal govt. should remove itself as the "compulsory middleman." The whole problem will be solved instantly.
RE:[object]
by abby Das on Mar 27, 2007 12:27 PM Permalink
Dear sanjay If your suggetion is granted by the Govt then there would be no scope for them to do "Trade Secret or secret Trade" with the industrialists.So they would never agree to let the induustrialists buy land ditrectly from the farmers.
The problem is that a ;portion of this "Secret Trade' is then passed donw the line and is used for purchasing the brains of a few educated people also who starts putting gas inside the BUdhdha Brand Baloon.It moves up in the air and people make a hype.BUt when it slamms,many of these purchased robots cannot tolerate if logics are given against them and documents are asked from them.They start behaving like Binoy Kongar and try to make people's life hell.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by trikarn on Mar 18, 2007 01:14 PM Permalink
finally a good solution, wholly sensible. let the market decide. no power land brokers bearing political affiliation. ref tamil nadu/karnatak etc. large tracts of revenue lands were gien for industry, private lands at market price. heard of this thing in andhra near hyd lots of farmers became rich overnite. got nearly 5 crores as land value from mncs. now let others decide. why buy cheap and sell dear the land belonging to others?bravo mr/.sanjay
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by Sudipto Nandan on Mar 18, 2007 12:47 PM Permalink
that is becoz law doesn't permit so. The wb cm wanted the new law in place so that the indutrialist can directly acquire alnds, but again the oppositions and the partners opposed themove. I feel, direct involvment of the land owners with the industiralist would have solved the problem a lot, like the case of Jindals,who are acquiring land 500 acres directly. Killing ppl was I dont think the actuall motive behind this massacre. But somehow I feel some policitcal reason was there--may be CPIM cadres were lossing ground in mednipur..may be CPIM wanted to kill those naxals and teach them a lesson...may be CPIM wanted to show there power!!! can be many things...whatever happened was not good..but this was necessary as common man should n't hold arms in any case
RE:RE:RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay on Mar 18, 2007 12:15 PM Permalink
Poor chap! You chose a facist, Stalinist as a hero.
Your hero has caused more problem than solving it. Now, even there will be LESS industrialization in WB. Because everybody is up in arams, specially the poor, against forceful land -grab.
RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by abby Das on Mar 27, 2007 12:22 PM Permalink
ABC I do not understand why only people talk about Mamata bannerjee.What is there in her that she needs to be discussed everwhere as the only opposition?It is a fact that Bengal never had a CM who can lie to this extent.BUt this doesn't mean that the CM post can be replaced only by Ms Mamata.There are more elligible candidates in the state.
I someties feel that people who consider only Mamata as the main oposition and discuss about her actually know inside them that she is the only person who could not be purchased til now by the CPM party.This incident actually indicates how CPM party is afaraid of her and is all reday to purchase her too as they did the others.(Not everyone)
RE:RE:CM responsible for Nandigram massacre
by hiral joshi on Mar 18, 2007 01:04 PM Permalink
This is exactly the language of a communist. When some one questions try to shut them up by hook or crook.
