Tata's family contributed lot for the country.If Tata is accquring a small land from farmer and giving employment,I donot believe they are doing any harm to the community.If WB government suspends the projects,then there are lot of states offer land to Tata,This so called Mamata and corrupt BJP crooks are not allowing to develop WB.
RE:RE:Tata's involvement of Development
by Governor General on Feb 26, 2007 07:22 AM Permalink
We don't know for sure. Tatas are one of the very ethical business houses of India. No question about it. India needs industrialization.. no one will argue against that too. But in a democracy people's voice has to be heard. Unless there is a populist support for stopping the Tata project.. politicians couldn't have artificially created trouble for so long. May be there is more to it than what meets our eyes. In the long run..it's better to concede to the demands of people.. I mean if the guy who has the land doesn't see the benefit in giving it away then please don't grab it from him. That's not ethical or fair to the farmer of Singur. I say this with heavy heart.. 'coz from whatever I see and hear Tata's project is the best thing that could've happened to Singur.
RE:RE:RE:Tata's involvement of Development
by ritwick sanyal on Feb 26, 2007 10:41 AM Permalink
Yeah but got only 5%-10% of the farmers u cant derail the project which 90%-95% ppl support..why else would u see more ppl working on the Tata Site than the number protesting..the figure of 500 ppl given here is also wrong..the correct figure is 350 pp protested and they were pushed back by 500 policemen..all the anti left parties wants to gain political mileage by protesting..and if u hear buddhadev bhattacharya and mamta banerjee's speect any educated person can tell that the CM has a vision and a roadmap for development which he is trying to implement while the opposition doesnt have any roadmap and protesting just coz its in opposition..i think bengal doesnt have any option but believe in the dreams of CM and follow his path..coz the opposition is hell bent on pulling the state backward while CM is trying his best to move ahead..
RE:Tata's involvement of Development
by abby Das on Mar 05, 2007 02:31 PM Permalink
Dear Mr Dilip Have the Tatas ever quantified the exact number of jobs that would be given to the villegers?how many of the posts would be filled by the outsiders?It is just a "secret Trade" done between the Tatas and Mr Nirupom Sen and Mr Budhdha Bhattacharya.
RE:Tata's involvement of Development
by Chandan Seal on Mar 05, 2007 02:29 PM Permalink
Dear Mr Dilip. "Tatas Giving Employement"...have the Tata group ever quantified the number of jobs that would be created inide the factory?How many local villagers and how many outsiders would get those jobs? It is just a "Secret Trade" done between mR Nirupom Se,Mr Budhdha Bhattacharaya and the tata group.
