Francois Gautier In India in true hindu spirit we never wrote history. If there is something good we can give to future generations we document it like vedas ,upandishads, yoga and tantra. We care only people who has something good to offer and document only good things that we can give to future generations. I suggest you should find better things to do
RE:History is unnecessary
by V H on Feb 16, 2007 11:47 PM Permalink
Naga - don't we have Romila's to document good things about Aurangzeb's, Babar's and others? Don't you think we need Francois to complete the rest of the document?
RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by Indian Muslim on Feb 16, 2007 11:51 PM Permalink
I have just one question for you VH. Answer me being honest with yourself .
How much hatred do you have for current-day muslims after reading the article ?
No need to be politically correct. I have seen enough hatred on the message boards , one more wont make any difference.
I just want to show you the intention of the Author - hate mongering. Thats all.
RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by V H on Feb 16, 2007 11:55 PM Permalink
Indian Muslim - Stop playing victim. Show some intellect instead of ignorance about everything
RE:RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by Indian Muslim on Feb 17, 2007 12:07 AM Permalink
What intellect do you want me to show to you ? How do you want me to show it ? Please tell me I will be glad to know ..
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by V H on Feb 17, 2007 12:47 AM Permalink
You are basically agreeing with me for the most part. Then why fight with me go fight your cousins who are still in 6th century. Message board savagery is nothing compared to what followers of Islam do everyday on Indian streets. I have witnessed first hand.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by Indian Muslim on Feb 17, 2007 12:41 AM Permalink
VH : This is for you.
Keeping my name as Indian Muslim, is MY CHOICE. IF you can keep VH , Do i question you on that?
What are you first by the way ?
Indian Muslim, as in an Indian following Islam as his religion . Whats Oxymoronic in that?
2) I am not against Common Civil Code. But I do want it to be a "Common" Code, Not a code which VH wants! You wouldnt ask the Kashmiris would you ? No, You would ask only whom you can show your power to.
3) I am not defending anybody over here. Ok. Throghout my years of growing, I read the same text book as you did.That Aurangzeb was hostile to hindus, and imposed Jaziya, converted hindus to muslims. I dont want to bring Shivaji neither do i support any looters or rapists.
If you really are against savagery then see the message board for yourself. The replies to Francois Article is Intellectual Savagery.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by V H on Feb 17, 2007 01:10 AM Permalink
The savagery I am talking is the number of BJP leaders being murdered across india on a daily basis. IM are confused people. We bring up the past you say come to present, we bring up present day issues like civil code etc, you say lets go back!!
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:History is unnecessary
by V H on Feb 17, 2007 12:27 AM Permalink
Stupid question. Though let me answer it, I am not anti-muslim, but I am anti-savagery.
Now to the intellectual part.
1) Why are you Indian Muslim...be human first and then an Indian. Indian Muslim is oxymoronic since all muslims are same since your rear points to one longitude and latitude.
2) Why in 2007 Kashimiri muslims passing Sharia law. Hindus want common civil code based on modern times. Why are you against it
3) If you are Indian muslim why are you defending invaders from outside who looted and raped this country? Dont bring concocted AIT theory and say everying is foreign in this land. Also stop bringing Shivaji here becoz Shivaji was defending native land and culture.
