The election in UP is round the corner and this type of provocative articles have started pouring in. Fellow Indians, Beware with this. At last we common man are the sufferers of the consequences of this kind of provocation.
RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by darshan b on Mar 05, 2007 08:57 AM Permalink
Hey my common man Do something. Why dont you write a column on your fellowmen who kill in the name of God and take a procession against them and then i will come with you to support you.
RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by manish varma on Mar 04, 2007 07:07 PM Permalink
Hi Farid and Sadiq, Nice to have decent chaps like you to discuss such issues in rational way and not maniacal way. Please think over following issues.
1. Is it incorrect that Aurangzeb demolished temples and built mosques? 2. Is it incorrect that he killed people for being hindus on religious lines, highly abhorable in today's civilized society? 3. Prima facie Gujarat CM can only be accused of not being able to take preventive actions, but AURANGZEB ORDERED EXECUTIONS OF HINDUS. Can this fact be denied? 4. If all these facts are correct, is not AURANGZEB AS BIG A CRIMINAL OF HISTORY AS HITLER.
Please think on these issues and then come against this article.
RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by In on Mar 05, 2007 07:46 PM Permalink
Who ever has killed or is killing innocents is criminal (without any Partiality). Comparing one with other is meaningless.
If someone is killing my friend and if I say I only didn't stopped the killer in doing so, (even though I had power); doesn't mean I was right. And also at the time it wasn't confirmed train mishappening was an accident or really it was attacked by anyone.
RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by sadiq hussain on Mar 06, 2007 06:26 PM Permalink
well i have nothing to say abt aurangazeb,he was on "TRUTH".He did not spare his own brothers for the sake of TRUE path.That was sacrifice.So,how many of us, watever religion ,can do this today? well i want ur private email if u dont mind to further keep blogging.Coz this has gone too long.Thanx.
RE:RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by Dr_Ramanand Rao on Mar 09, 2007 03:27 PM Permalink
So, was Hitler also 'on truth'? Aurangzeb killed his brothers so they would not pose a threat to his throne
RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by darshan b on Mar 05, 2007 09:17 AM Permalink
Hey my common man Do something. Why dont you write a column on your fellowmen who kill in the name of God and take a procession against them and then i will come with you to support you.
RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by Ankit Khanna on Mar 04, 2007 11:57 AM Permalink
Hi Farid, I fail to understand what is provocative about the article. It points a finger at a 17th century maniac for his cruelty and not at Muslims in general.
It can seem provocative only to someone who beleives in the doctrine of Aurangzeb. Do you ??
And please, where did up elections arrive like a bolt from the blue ?? Get out of the consiparcy theory mindset. This article is not against muslims, its against Aurangzeb !!
RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by sadiq hussain on Mar 04, 2007 04:47 PM Permalink
Dear lovely Ankit,my dear ankit,U should know what is good wat is wrong,leave alone 17 th century,tell us all about Gujarat riots.i think those were not so loooooooong ago.Saddam was hanged for killing a cpl of hundrend of kurds.Do u dare to plead USA to mete out same punishment to The then GUJ CM?Food 4 thought,well u think abt it fella.
RE:RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by Dr_Ramanand Rao on Mar 09, 2007 03:17 PM Permalink
The Gujarat riots were in retaliation to muslim aggressiveness. Take the recent demolition of a dargah in the middle of a Road in Baroda - didn't muslims retaliate?
RE:RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by shawaji bhosale on Mar 04, 2007 08:14 PM Permalink
ear sadiq, leave alone 5 years back old things happened in gujarat, how about talking few months back train blast in mumbai? cdo you dare to pleade Bush to carpet bomb all muslims mohallas for that?
RE:RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by Ankit Khanna on Mar 04, 2007 09:18 PM Permalink
Well sadiq, this is exactly what i mean by the 'conspiracy theory syndrome' affecting so many muslim youth like you.
I questioned Aurangzeb and I recieved replies ranging from UP elections, to Gujarat to Iraq.
I'll tell you Guajarat was a crime .. do you accept that Aurangzeb was a criminal ?? If you can, then please answer in a yes or no ... and, for God's sake, for once, please do not drag Bush into the debate !!!
RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by praveen thakur on Mar 04, 2007 08:58 PM Permalink
dear sadique, If you speak for Gujrat Riot you should not forget about the brytual killing of innocent hindus in the train which was the instant reason of the riot? You this was a secular act done by Muslims? Or you wanna say if muslim kills Pandits in Kashmir this is Jehad? Where do you hide at that time Mr. Seculars?
RE:RE:RE:RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by Dr_Ramanand Rao on Mar 09, 2007 03:23 PM Permalink
The Gujarat riots were in retaliation to muslim aggressiveness. Take the recent demolition of a dargah in the middle of a Road in Baroda - didn't muslims retaliate? Retaliation should be expected when something is wrong
RE:The truth about Aurangzeb
by darshan b on Mar 05, 2007 08:56 AM Permalink
Hey my common man Do something. Why dont you write a column on your fellowmen who kill in the name of God and take a procession against them and then i will come with you to support you.
