whenever i think of west bengal, i get a picture of poverty all around, why can't we stand together with development. I suggest a negotiation should happen between two parties. No one had right to stop any sort of development.
RE:RE:what is right
by pramit nag on Feb 10, 2007 10:50 PM Permalink
WestBengal is shining and it will shine only because of our current responsible and practical CM.Industry can't go against farming and history proved it again and again but when wealth is coming through industrialists, who the hell is this Trinamool leader and her few supporters to protest and stop it.They are already out of bengal politics and will be wiped out in next election completely.We know much better that who is good and who is bad and who can give us stability and who can ruin us...so bye bye Mamatadi...your retirement countdown begins here
RE:what is right
by kuntal kumar roy on Feb 10, 2007 04:59 PM Permalink
You are right Mr. Basli Toppo that everywhere of West Bengal you may find proverty !! but this is only because of CPM !! They never tried to develop the state. now they are taking the main agricultural lad of source !! they are not willing to take any unresoursfull land !! what is the sence behind this !!!
RE:RE:what is right
by Anisur Rahman on Feb 10, 2007 06:07 PM Permalink
Poor guys, have you ever visited other parts of India? Just come out of your AC rooms and see the poverty level on all the states like Orissa, AP, Karnataka also...At least in WB people are getting foods now a days...The rationalization of land - biggest achievements of Left Front govt and they are still in power due to that...And you fools are talking about kind of Gundaraj!!!Few steps of Left Front govt. is not done in a correct way...but who is the replacement of Left Front in WB? Nobody...Mamta banerjee is well known for her "drama" - and how people will believe a fake "doctorate"...GO to Texas,Dallas - at least read history...will understand that whatever CM Buddhadeb Bhattacharyya is doing is directed towars the improvement of not only WB - but whole of INDIA...
RE:RE:RE:what is right
by dhulipala manoj on Feb 10, 2007 07:51 PM Permalink
Before pointing out somebody find out the correct details.... do you know the poverty levels in AP and Karnataka? Stop talking about others try to develop your state first before comparing with others... West Bengal has more resources than AP both natural resources and a metro like Kolkata... AP does nto have abundant natural resources and even Hyderabad started developing because of its people, it does not have a port and metro like Kolkata which Britishers developed.... Yes, AP might be behind WB in some ways but what you should see how fast is AP developing??? I dont care about the political system in your state but if you take the name of my state or Southern India we would not sit back and leave it... because it is a people's movement that is developing South not the policies of our governments....
RE:RE:RE:RE:what is right
by Anisur Rahman on Feb 10, 2007 09:19 PM Permalink
Boss I know the poverty level of AP, Karnataka and Orissa also...Am a computer scientist and have done several govt of India projects where all these statistics were necessary...and I have all statistics with me...I am not throwing words like you...I have 5 year statistics with me...You pointed out AP is developing fast...Do you know as of today kolkata is developing more? Do you know how many people of Karnataka is below poverty level...Don't say bullshits like "my state or southern India"...I myself were previously staying at hyd and now staying at B'lore...so what? TRUTH IS TRUTH...Have you ever visited Orossa? Do you know the poverty level of the state? Better before acting smart - "have proper details"...Ans no feelings like north, south, East, West...Why you people always have feeling about south? Mind that Statistics doesn't depend upon feelings...Lastly what you have said has no relevance with the topic of discussion...Do you understand that? Its not a tussle...Its comparison...healthy...Do know know the meaning of that?
RE:RE:what is right
by satyajit shome on Feb 10, 2007 05:34 PM Permalink
DEAR KUNTAL, DAYS ARE GONE OF GUNDAGRDDI, IF IT A MASS MOVEMENT NO ONE CAN STOP IT, BUT SEEING THE PAST HISTORY OF TRINAMUL OR SPECIALLY MS MAMATA,WE ARE VERY WORIED ABOUT HIS MENTAL FRAME, AS EVEN AFTER GEETING CHANCE TO DEVELOP HOME STATES AS A RAILWAY MINISTER , HE ONLY MAKE NOISES AND ULTEMETLY RESIGN, WHO WE BELIVE IN HER, THAT HE CAN DO ANYTHINK POSITIVE, NOT EVEN ABLE TO HOLD THE CORPORATION AFTER MUCH FANEFARE WIN, AND EVERY ONE KNOWS THAT LEFTFRONT HAS DONE MUCH IN THE AGRICULTURAL FRONT THAN ANY ONE IN INDIA, AND EVEN EVERY EDUCATED PERSON CAN UNDERSTAND THAT WITHOUT INDUSTRY NO STATE CAN BE DEVELOP, AND INDUSTRY WILL NOT BE HAPPENED IN AIR, AND WHEN A PERSON INVEST SO MUCH HE WILL NEED APPROPRIATE POSITION TO DEVELOP THE INDUSTRY, AS BECOUSE NOW A DAYS COMPETITION IS VERY MUCH, SO PLEASE DON,T MISLEAD AND CHECK YOUR MENTAL FRAME BEFORE INSISTING TO TAKE ARMS, BECAUSE DAYS ARE GONE FOR GUNDAGARDI, HOPE YOU WILL UNDERSTAND,
RE:RE:RE:what is right
by sumit biswas on Feb 10, 2007 06:12 PM Permalink
its people like Kuntal who really harm West bengal's cause.....I really do not get his point of view....what does he intend to do?....take on the CPI(M)'s musclepower or its smoothly-drilled machinery?.....we the common people know what's good for us and at this moment, its the industrialization of the state....if the ruling party's doing it and a pranskter is opposing it, we obviously know who to support!!!....we have also seen what good the non-CPI(M) parties are actually capable of doing.....so, people in WB who've got any grey matter in their head know what to do and why the recent flareup is happening....its time we stopped the political gameplay and holding the economy to ransom by defying the mundane stupid Bandhs that are being called!!!
RE:RE:what is right
by arindam chakraborty on Feb 10, 2007 05:23 PM Permalink
You r very much wrong both Mr.Kuntal n Mr.Toppo.U donot know the real picture of WB, so its better if u make no comments w/o any prior information of WB.WB is now rapidly changing to the right direction of industrialisation.With d IT sectors hovering all around and also manufacturing sectors is coming in WB, d scenario is changing.All of us should support the process of industrialisation.If u want to do good with 10 persons, there is a possibility of 2 persons being harmed. And mainly the crazy opposition parties( i doubt if there any opposition in WB) are trying to take the wind in their sail from this. The need of this hour is to solve the ongoing fiasco in WB and look forward for the industry. Arindam Chakraborty
RE:RE:RE:what is right
by stephen raj on Feb 10, 2007 05:38 PM Permalink
Mr. Arindam, your theory of harming 2 persons for the good of 10 does not hold right. we cannot justify wrong means for even right end. we alwys think for the good of the a small percentage of rich, elite class forgetting the majority of the poor including the states run by the Leftists. Without ensuring hustice for the poor agricultral labourers we cannot go for industrialization which is in fact good. but the priority should go for the development of the vast majority of the poor.
RE:RE:RE:what is right
by Anisur Rahman on Feb 10, 2007 10:07 PM Permalink
Yes Mr Arindam Chakraborty, you are right.The persons who are pointing out the poverty level of WB doesn't have any idea about the poverty level of other states. Also in reality - you want to do good for 100 people and actually doing good for 80 -90 and 10-20 persons are being harmed little bit - readily acceptable.But the reverse is not AT ALL Acceptable. And the problem with oppositions (if it exists at all) in WB, they don't follow any rules and regulations of their own. Whatever ruling party is doing they blindly protest that - without understanding its future benefit. All good wisher of WB must support the process of industrialization of WB. And Mr. Kuntal and Mr. Toppo's thinking (Are they really thinking?) is very very wrong.Hope you understand.
RE:RE:RE:what is right
by Shibaji Mukherjee on Feb 10, 2007 07:35 PM Permalink
Mr. Raj I agree with your view, but you need to understand that in any event in life you'll not be able to make 10/10 people happy, you need to consider things in the majority good perspective. Industrialization, that is happening in WB is not elite targeted, note that they are setting up manufacturing units and SEZ for manufacturing unit.. it will provide jobs to lot of blue collar worker, lots of support industry in the small scale sector. Well people without any skill or education will not get jobs , but at least people with some amount of skill/education will get employment and also they can be trained. You don't need BTech or BE degree to be considered. Growing the manufacturing sector is the only way for all inclusive growth
