By now it must be clear that Karnataka will file a review/writ petition with the Tribunal. Does anybody know how long is that process ? I mean how long the tribunal takes to announce the reviewed verdict ? Should the Karnataka should be legally bound to adhere to the Verdict until the review petition's verdict ???
RE:how long the writ petition process takes ?
by raj on Feb 08, 2007 03:22 PM Permalink
Verdict is only a recommendation.Karnataka will file a review petition and the final judgement will take about one year time.Even then, it doesnt become Law, it has to be legitimised as Law by passing the bill in parliament.
TN or anybody cannot enforce to release the water as per the verdict, Karnataka can say, I will not be able to release water citing whatever reasons they want...
In the meantime, we can definitely convince the courts of the reality and get the justice. Assuming that, Courts go wrong again, we can always protest and stop the verdict becoming a Law.
As long it is an Unimplmentable solution, Nobody can force us to release water.
The only solution will be TN's acceptance to Karnataka's Proposal. My dear kannadigas we need not worry about Tamils, We just need to protest strongly , legally , Thats it.
RE:RE:how long the writ petition process takes ?
by maignanam chandran on Feb 09, 2007 10:25 AM Permalink
hi raj,
i find you constantly highlighting issues of "tamil" instead of our "water problem". Lets not forget both tamils and kannadigas live in both the states alongwith other people. So instead of addressing as "tamils" & "kannadigas", please as an Indian address the issue as between states. Hope you take me in right spirit and mend your ways. - A Bangalorean
RE:how long the writ petition process takes ?
by raj on Feb 08, 2007 03:22 PM Permalink
Verdict is only a recommendation.Karnataka will file a review petition and the final judgement will take about one year time.Even then, it doesnt become Law, it has to be legitimised as Law by passing the bill in parliament.
TN or anybody cannot enforce to release the water as per the verdict, Karnataka can say, I will not be able to release water citing whatever reasons they want...
In the meantime, we can definitely convince the courts of the reality and get the justice. Assuming that, Courts go wrong again, we can always protest and stop the verdict becoming a Law.
As long it is an Unimplmentable solution, Nobody can force us to release water.
The only solution will be TN's acceptance to Karnataka's Proposal. My dear kannadigas we need not worry about Tamils, We just need to protest strongly , legally , Thats it.
