1) Why every educated Muslim from India wants to migrate to US,UK,France,Australia etc. I have never heard or seen any of these educated guys standing in queues to seek Indonesian, Sudanese, Saudi Arabian or Yemeni work visas. If they hate US so much then why the hell you want to go there at any cost???
2) Why 9 out of 10 small town or city in India has a muslim as the most noted criminal?
3) Why no Muslim worth his salt crticizes the innumerable & ridiculous fatwas that their Maulvis issue at the drop of a hat?
4) Why Muslims take Govt subsidy for HAJ when their quran does not approve it?
Seek some logical and educated replies,if any Muslim has one.
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by americaisgreat on Dec 25, 2007 01:32 AM Permalink
fyi...there are more indian muslims in saudi than anywhere in the world.
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by vasu_erfolg on Dec 25, 2007 01:37 AM Permalink
That is because the saudis have such horrible living conditions (socially) that no self-respecting non-muslim would want to subject himself to such humiliation.
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by rajat on Dec 25, 2007 01:48 AM Permalink
Your questions are inherently racist and based on factually unsubstantiated premises. People like you are the reason our country is ill. (yes, ill. No progress is worth anything if not all sections of our country sees equally the benefits of that progress.)
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by Rana on Dec 25, 2007 02:08 AM Permalink
You are right sajal i am in USA and i know how these GUJRATIS are spoiling the image of India here
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by Suresh J on Dec 25, 2007 09:56 AM Permalink
I am in US too and i don;t see Gujjus spoiling any name. Infact if anything, they are regarded as best business men.
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by parimal shah on Dec 25, 2007 02:08 AM Permalink
dear friend, you are right on the information what u have, but you have outdated information..Also seems that you are jealous on gujaratis...Why?????
RE:Seeking answers from educated Muslims
by indriyo on Dec 25, 2007 02:35 AM Permalink
well, it doesnt need a Muslim to point out the fallacy in your questions. Any sensible person knows your assertions are totally wrong. Anyway, let me try my hand 1) There is no statistical evidence which suggests that Muslims are emigrating more than other religious groups 2) Totally false. If you are talking about major crimes like terrorist acts, yes. There is a correlation between those crimes and people who proclaim themselves as Muslims (?). However, there is absolutely no evidence in police records or even military records that Muslims commit more crime than others 3) There are quite a lot of Muslims reformists and religious leaders who criticize hardliners very similar to Hindu or other religious reformists. Take the case of Salman Rushdie, Taslima or Imams who vehemently criticized fundamentalism when few Afgan leaders called on Indian Muslim community to come and fight in Afganistan. 4) The HAJ pilgrimage is planned to compensate the lower budget allocated to Mosques or Muslim holidays in this country. In TN, there are govt sponsored trips to Parasakthi temples, in Kerala there are govt sponsored facilities for Aiyappan pilgrimage, etc. You can look up the rest!
Agreed that every religion needs reforms. But it can happen only if everyone is united and not discriminated based on religion. Indian democracy and constitution is very elite and noble in handling these moral issues, only the community needs to realize it.
