Surprisingly author of this Article wants to dismiss Modi, but just by his own standard like "he is wrong because I say so" no rational, no proof, nothing.
Mr. Parvin Sheth doesn't take any of the claims Modi and his administrations has made and is making in their campaign, and then make argument against it, rather just keep ranting on things which are mostly speculative, personal feelings and cannot be proven.
For ex. He goes "His imaginative adoption of the 'yellow' model of economic growth (taken from Eastern Tiger countries%u2026." and "imaginative introduction of SEZs and port-based development%u2026"
So, if some try to do something which you disagree with, that becomes "Imaginative" ?
Also, he seems to be quite knowledgably about castes in Gujarat, but also seems to forget many other castes like Baniyas, Bhramins and so on%u2026
If you read entire article author seems to dripping with feeling of anti-Modiesm rather than writing based on facts, which what a "Journalist" is supposed to do.
RE:Personal feelings or Journalism....
by Satya a on Dec 13, 2007 09:00 PM Permalink
I wonder why the intelligentsia all over the planet are anti-Modi, while the rest seem to drool over Modi. I really wonder why! Contrast the Tarun Tejpals with the Babu Bajrangis.
RE:Personal feelings or Journalism....
by sanjay choudhry on Dec 13, 2007 09:12 PM Permalink
India's intellegent is leftist / commie and anti-national to the core. For years they took bribes from the USSR. Read Mitrokin archives. What do you expect?
RE:Personal feelings or Journalism....
by Sherry Thomas on Dec 13, 2007 09:17 PM Permalink
dude..take a break...what do u mean to say wen indias intelligentsia is leftist...ur comment obviosly shows u as ignorant
RE:Personal feelings or Journalism....
by sanjay choudhry on Dec 13, 2007 09:23 PM Permalink
One-liners don't prove anything. What makes you think India's intelligentsia is not leftist?
And when are you allowing pagans entry into your heaven?
RE:Personal feelings or Journalism....
by Stee on Dec 13, 2007 09:38 PM Permalink
Satya goes "I wonder why the intelligentsia all over the planet are anti-Modi" well, it depends how you define "intelligentsia" , if having some linguistic skills - especially in English - is your definition for so called "intelligentsia" then good luck.
In Europe there is only one country which predominantly speaks English - that is Great Britain
As far, Tarun Tejpal and Babu Bajranji goes, I haven't seen/read report, only thing I know is meaning of "Bajrangi" it relates to more Shiv Sena...
