Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Perticular Community
by Abbas Rumani on Dec 12, 2007 06:27 PM   Permalink | Hide replies

My dear friends
Give me a break- You want a Fatwa i give you a FATWA that thes terorist are skwed head and their elimination is the only option.
Does this solved you problem. Khumani gave Fatwa against Salman Rushid. What happen? has any body killed him?
There is fatwa agains Taslim Nasrin. Right. Has any body killed her?
I am not justifying fatwa. what i am saying that FATWA is not what a "Perticular Community" think it is.
There are different type of acts are committed by people. every day and every where it is happening.but "perticluar cumminity" just look for a "perticular community" person involvement and if they find that they start blame bashing and abusing that community.
I am a Indian and Muslim. I have seen Muslim fanatic as well as Hindu Fanatic. unfortunatly i find both of the barbaric.
Some one blasting a bomb and killing Innocent people is as barbaric as some one killing inncent people by sward, Cut open a mother womb and killing a unborn baby.
Both say they have done this for their religion and community and if any religion allows such thing than i am not ready to accept that religion as a true and right religion



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
  RE:RE:Perticular Community
by Raj Kumar on Dec 12, 2007 07:12 PM   Permalink
man there is nothing called HINDU fanatic , if hindus were fanatic then we can never see a muslims in india, imagine in a muslim majority country if a hindu person try to convert them to hindu this guys will be killed and he will never see the sun light agian.

Man we know were is the true broad minded people are, dont try to smart ok............

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Perticular Community
by Dibyendu on Dec 12, 2007 07:39 PM   Permalink
My brother- all agree that fanaticism is barbaric, but brother just as Hindus oppose the fanaticism of Hindus, it is Muslims themselves who have to oppose the fanaticism of Muslims- others may be able to do some constructive crticism, but only Muslims themselves have to seek enlightenment and help themselves. And talking of fatwas- they only serve to depict the mind set of a community- what the community feels is right and what it fels is wrong. It is obvious that the community feel Taslima is wrong and dangerous whereas the jihadis are right and correct. Has any leader of the community openly come out to denounce and condemn the jihadis? Not one that I no of has yet, even though these jihadis have been killing Indians for 2 decades- and that is a long time my brother. Please enlighten your community members to come out of the middle age mindset and accept plurality- the world shall see you differently then

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
  RE:Perticular Community
by Indian Taurus on Dec 12, 2007 06:43 PM   Permalink
My dear Good Muslim brother Abbas Rumanai !
Your words sound very reasonable and impartial but the crucks of the matter is who initiates this violence. I had a friend in my school days who used to tease and torture his colleagues and start weaping as soon a teacher is in sight. Result, the tortured used to get more lectures on tolerance. In India majority Hindus have more lessons to face by ruling elites and Muslims are talking in terms of their vote-bank power or else a further division of the mother-land. I am sorry. Use of the respectful term "vande-mother" for the land is blasphemy in their religious code. Look at Malayesia, how they are intending to treat Hindu (terrorists if they are) ! This is the way the Hindus are treated in Muslim countries. They would again like to impose Jaziya on Hindus but the problem is they want to be treated as cultured ones ! In such an atmosphere, where is the scope of accomodation for your good words !

   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Pak may let jihadis into India: Lt Gen