There was a tragedy. A complete compartment got burned. People died.
OR
There was a conspiracy. A bogie was meticulously burned and its passengers killed.
Be it either ways. What should a government do? Try and get the situation under control, immediately, using all the available resources. Using all available resources, find the cause of the incident. If it is a tragedy, provide succor to the bereaved. If it was a conspiracy, hunt down the accused and put them on trial.
What did actually happen? And therein lies the tragedy. All your short-sighted comments about sob-nobody-talks-about-Hindus-being-killed and Muslims-started-it and Muslims-deserve-it and other very similar comments look eerily like a well oiled plan to not discuss the real issue at all.
You can fool some people all the time, all the people some time but not all the people all the time.
RE:No Justification!!
by Ramesh Anand on Dec 12, 2007 06:46 PM Permalink
Ismail Sayyad, there was another conspiracy to defame Muslims.American destroyed World Trade Centre NewYork with help of Goons who were actually paid by USA govt and killed 4000 americans so that American develope hatred for Muslims.These Hindus and Americans are EK HEE THAALI KE CHATTE-BATTE.
RE:No Justification!!
by VB on Dec 12, 2007 04:36 PM Permalink
yes it was a conspiracy of Congress .... who wanted to benefit by it... but it went all wrong for them
RE:No Justification!!
by chanakya maurya on Dec 12, 2007 06:17 PM Permalink
When a state is in favour of the goondas, the gudaism will spread across the nation. And when a Vivekanand comes on the scene in the form of a Narendra, the goondas start crying wolf because their goonda regime would come to an end.
RE:No Justification!!
by Demo-crazy on Dec 12, 2007 08:07 PM Permalink
Very pertinent point about what happened to the rail coach and there after.
1. The government may have failed (or acted slow) in the aftermath of the rail coach incident. 2. The tit for tat, took too many lives. When mobs takeover the streets no government can do much. 3. Did only Muslims die in the riots following that incident. I have read that even there were retaliatory / counter riots which hit the Hindus hard.
Point is violence is not the solution for any problem. Who caused the initial trigger? Did those karsevaks deserve such death? What about other innocent people in that coach who were not affiliated with any movement?
The power of non-cooperation is more stronger and unfortunately, that is what the Muslims suffer in Gujarat. The only way to change things is resolve to not make such mistakes again. Ensure you and your Hindu brethern accept past mistakes and do not succumb to what the narrow minded politicians preach.
RE:No Justification!!
by on Dec 13, 2007 12:55 AM Permalink
Why always Hindus suffer??? Why you expect no Reaction from Hindu Society for Action against them? After 15 yrs of Babri (Ram Janm Bhoomi) statue demolished, still we are getting Reactions for that... And 1992-93 Mumbai suffered for Babri... Bomb Blast and communal riots... After Godhra... first time Hindu reacted strongly... simple
