Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
How many?
by Milind on Dec 23, 2007 10:58 AM   Permalink | Hide replies

In the aftermath of the 2002 Godhra carnage, 1,000 Muslims died and many others were injured.

Does anyone know how many Hindus died in the same? or counting dead Hindus is prohibited in India?

These are just allegation (or foul cry) who knows what is the truth? syed is just showing the dark side of the state without providing enough evidence...

These kinds of stories can be written plentiful!


    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:How many?
by Ankur Shah on Dec 23, 2007 01:28 PM   Permalink
well said.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:RE:How many?
by tariq qazi on Dec 23, 2007 03:18 PM   Permalink
islam never says to kill any innocent person

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:How many?
by on Jan 02, 2008 11:47 PM   Permalink
MR TARIQ , U R RIGHT THAT ISLAM NEVER SUPPORTS TO KILL ANYONE,INFACT NO RELIGION SAYS TO KILL ANYONE....BUT THE PROBLEM LIES IN THE INTERPRETATION OF ISLAM....I DON'T WANT TO COMMENT UPON TEACHINGS OF QURAN...BUT EVERY MUSLIM INTERPRETS JIHAD ACCORDING TO HIS OWN WILL..... FOR SOME ITS ABOUT KILLING THE EVIL IN YOUR INNERSELF...FOR SOME ITS ABOUT SLAUTERRING ALL THE NON MUSLIMS...AND THEN THESE PEOPLE RELATE TO HOLY PATH....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:RE:RE:How many?
by Pradeep Ingle on Dec 23, 2007 04:36 PM   Permalink
Mr Tariq, then Why r Islamist killing innocent persons??????Why r the terrorists given shelter in Muslim Dominated areas?Read any mewspaper and u will see that half of the crimes in India are done by Muslims..... Why?Take a look at any Muslim dominated city and u will find that crime rates are CLEARLY HIGH,(eg-Malegaon),Why?I dont think u have answer to these questions...Its high time that u people interospect ur religion...decide what is logical and what is illogical...I do not intend to hurt u friend but this is a fact and something needs to be done in this regard urgently.....Dont u think so?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:How many?
by tariq qazi on Dec 23, 2007 07:51 PM   Permalink
i admit there is lack of education in muslim society some of u try keeping education away from them ....
As terrorism is concern i have also passed through this test, few days back some body has given letter to police , PM that CM mayawati that i going to murdered them with my name and address, several intelligence egncies came to my residence and office to interrogte me and my family (they asked everything gentally) but u know the level of allegation that anyone could bear with ...they didnt find anything wrong with me and my family since my ancestors...we were shoked who have done this.....
this could not be done by any mslim breothers

u know what kind of untrustworthy work some people are its hard to trust at this moment....

some people are too cheap they can do anything for proving them right ......
what would u teach ur children speak lie hate truth....if this please go ahead

no body could help such people

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:RE:How many?
by kamlesh mirchandani on Dec 23, 2007 09:15 PM   Permalink
Let me inform you what i know about muslims
Muslims have 100% literacy rate as they can read and write and can read the kuran(the sacred book teaches how to leave life peacefully) you cannot say muslims are illiterate, Muslims are the most educated but the worst followers (Most of muslims study islam and break rule) But in hindus you will find the illiterate people who dont read Geeta or other sacred books but they work according to their hearts which is always softer then muslims (Most hindus will faint even if they see blood of an animal then how can they slaughter this is only those who live with muslims and become strong enough to resist) and the case you have discussed as far as you say muslims brothers can not do this
i have seen muslims killing muslims so better be aware of the near and dear living with you tried to trick you may be for some money matter or some jealousy or some old enimity. dont blame anyone without proof. I have lived with the real muslims ate with them celebrated RAMADAN with them doing cooking and eating at sehri and in evening sharing the blessings

so whatch your step in posting anything which increases hatred in communities this can become dangerous for you and your family as
most muslims favour pakistan (where still india migrated muslims are treated as muhazirs) so for the sake of the country prosperity you can be traped
Be Aware

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:How many?
by tariq qazi on Dec 23, 2007 03:27 PM   Permalink
our islam is balanced on every every points of life's every seconds activities allah says jo cheese maine tumare kiye ki use use karo uske bahar mat jao kurbani ke liye kuch selected animals uneh khao insano ko mat khao noida nithare kand main aur aram se jinda raho

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:RE:How many?
by kamlesh mirchandani on Dec 23, 2007 09:29 PM   Permalink
Islam is realy balanced if you really follow it but its not followed properly
people marry several wifes who take permision from previous wife (according to islam permision is required) marry only if you are well enough strong to feed and satisfy the brides (but who cares) give equal rites (never given)
i have given this example because muslims read kuran and give arguments that they follow islam
in actual they don't
but for hindus they follow what they are taught in family and mostly they are taught to be polite,soft hearted,and to follow live and let live policy (infact you compare hinduism and islam or any other religion you will find teach only one thing watch you step dont split on others) HINDI hai HUMWATAN hai HINDUSITAN HAMARA
SARE JAHAAN se ACHHA ye GULISTAN HAMARA

Please dont spoil it spreading heatred
always try to show good ways to people not the bad parts
for gujarat voilence what ever it was it was shit
but you cannot work keeping that incident in mind
So many hindu families died without food so people suicide due to no buisness and inability to pay debpts of loan
but have you seen any hindu in gujarat or any where just crying and showing wounds
and gujarat voilence was the answer to godhara

leave everythig be constructive for humanity
you will get nothing blaming other


   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
'For Modi, Muslims don't exist'