I don%u2019t think talking with few people and putting there experience will generalize the statement that Modi is bad for all Muslims. By this massage, all other Muslims who even don%u2019t have such experience also starts feeling Modi as anti Muslim because it is considered religious then. Role of media plays a very important role in such cases. Can we talk or discuss experience of a person as an Individual keeping aside his religion? If we really love India and want the progress of India, we should not involve any religion into it. If there is any issue with a person, he should be looked as a suffering Indian, not Hindu or Muslim. The examples given in the massage like this is always generalized to religious. There might be people from Hindus too, who might be suffered from government.
RE:Does this shows the opinion of all Muslims
by mohd zahid on Dec 11, 2007 10:49 PM Permalink
a very sensible comment..but the fact remains that one person is accused of heinous crimes comitted against a paricular community and is proven beyond doubt that he is an audacious criminal. i strongly feel that there are many resonable people in every community who believe that no religion endorses inhuman acts.. but because it is written in the holy books which every muslim has to believe that God may forgive many major sins but not murder or killing of innocent people (as so called alqaeda is doing across the globe).any way no offence intended towards anybody... May God give minimum intellect to mankind
RE:Does this shows the opinion of all Muslims
by asdfg on Dec 11, 2007 10:56 PM Permalink
zahid bhai, yaar aap ek side ki baaten karte ho. afzal guru ko SC ne saja di lekin uske liye aap kuch nahi bolte? judicary is pretty dysfunctional there correct? but when nothing has been proved against Modi, you cry foul? What hypocriscy yaar. Thoda to strong bano? call a spade for a spade ALWAYS. God bless All.
RE:Does this shows the opinion of all Muslims
by Mohammed AliSherKhan on Dec 11, 2007 11:00 PM Permalink
Seems you not like Islam? No maulana ever issue fatwa against al qaueda / its leaders? If they bad, then why no fatwa? Why fatwa on Tasleema / Solmon?
RE:Does this shows the opinion of all Muslims
by Chet on Dec 12, 2007 03:34 AM Permalink
Many maulana do not accept what all cai da is doing? still they don't dare to issue fatwa
