RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by QandA on Aug 31, 2007 02:12 AM Permalink
By not agreeing to something even just for the sake of saying you prove exactly the point Buddha is trying to make. You will never evolve beyond your teachings., Even if all the Humanity travels to Mars or moon there also you will point in the direction of Eart 'Cos that where Mecca is right?
If Hindus can love Sher O Shayari why can't the Muslims sing Vande Mataram. That's exactly the point Buddha is trying to make. Your Islamic teaching doesn't allow you to experiment. It doesn't allow you any freedom for any thought process and this halts the evolution of a Muslim mind..
Why R U blindly follwing any teachings? In Hinduism we have freedom to criticize and even correct any Hindu intepretations? When can this happen in Islam?
Why are U blindly following Allah? If U agree that this Universe is the reflection of GOD then U are stupid to beleive that this GOD or nature is forzen as a book written by your Allah. Look around this Earth and Universe is chaging evey second. How can something 1400 years ago could be true today.. Stop follwoing any Koran or any teachings. They are in their times. The Universe (which is a reflection of GOD) has changed in a million ways by now..
RE:RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by imran patel on Aug 31, 2007 02:16 AM Permalink
What is the significance of VANDE MATARAM with respect to PATRIOTISM ???
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by naresh kaushik on Aug 31, 2007 02:47 AM Permalink
VANDE MATARAM means we belong to a single mother, that is why it is mandatory,if any doubt please go back to the history,how your fore fathers mothers and sisters were tortured to get converted into ISLAM, no matter if you are fallowing ISLAM but you belong to one Mother that is INDIA hence Vande Mataram Mother India,
RE:RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by imran patel on Aug 31, 2007 03:43 AM Permalink
Naresh, I have one Mother, the one that gave birth to me. India is my birthplace.
Why can I not make that distinction ???
Tomorrow someone will say that lets call it Father instead of Mother...
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by imran patel on Aug 31, 2007 03:50 AM Permalink
So does a person from Pakistan/Bangladesh/Nepal/Burma/greater India sing "Vande Mataram"...
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by Vishal bharadwaj on Aug 31, 2007 02:36 AM Permalink
sometimes it is necessary to sing a song which was the bloodline of our freedom fighters, to reinstate the same spirit, yes by knowing the meaning and magnitude of the song , i think it will surely make one patriotic by singing it, mainly children who by their age and maturity learn more by singing
RE:RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by on Aug 31, 2007 04:08 AM Permalink
About your comment about quran "How can something 1400 years ago could be true today"... I don't comment about a book without knowing the content... Please try to read about Professor Moore and about his sayings about quran. He was so amazed at the accuracy of the descriptions and the terminology used for the various stages of the development of the embryo that he modified his own textbook on the subject. He incorporated all the relevant Qur%u2019anic passages and authentic statements of the Prophet Muhammad into his book, The Developing Human: Clinically oriented embryology with Islamic additions, which was published by WB Saunders in 1987 and was a standard university textbook in the United States. The book now contains passages of the Qur%u2019an and the Hadeeth (verified statements of the Prophet Muhammad) for every stage of development and Professor Moore has also adopted the classification used in the above two sources.
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by Sadaf Kapoor on Aug 31, 2007 02:11 AM Permalink
WHy did the maulvis gave the stupid fatwa that IMrana who was raped by father-in-law has to treat her husband as son and her father-in-law as husband... Gudia was married to a guy when her 1st husband was missing ..when he came back she had to ditch him and again go back to her 1st hubby that too when she had got kids with 2nd hubby???h
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by imran patel on Aug 31, 2007 02:15 AM Permalink
The Maulvies were dead wrong. PERIOD !!!
In my humble opinion... In the case of Imrana, the Father-in-Law must be tried and punished for RAPE.
In the case of Gudia, she should have got the divorce before getting married again. Given the fact that it did not happen, she should have a divorse later.
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by Sadaf Kapoor on Aug 31, 2007 02:18 AM Permalink
But recently in a tv report --It was shown that Imrana is still treated badly by the whole village...Most of the villagers consider maulviii to be correct and wanna go by that
RE:RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by Sadaf Kapoor on Aug 31, 2007 02:46 AM Permalink
So you admit muslims are largely ignorant bcoz no hindu even the most uneducated and poor ones think sati was good...they condemn it ...
RE:Stop malpractices and fatwas
by imran patel on Aug 31, 2007 02:22 AM Permalink
Should I blame the Hindu faith for SATI...Absolutely No. The society was ignorant. Customs superseded religious values.
Same thing in the village. These are ignorant people who cannot read or write and are following a half knowledge Maulvi...
