Friends, who are these left that are opposing the Nuke deal - lets get to some history about them.. 1. these left are the same people who had got several Indian freedom fighter arrested during World War 2, 1945-46, at Soviet Russia's instance. 2. these Left are the very same people who has taken China's side when 1962 Indo-Chinese war broke out. They even raised fund for Chinese soldiers in India. 3. They had called respected freedom fighter Netaji Subhas Bose "DOG." 4. Today they want to stop the Nuke deal the instance of China's Communist party. Can we Indians trust these very same Left with India's national interest? Decide for yourself, but only after carefully going thru Left%u2019s history.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by dinesh kumar on Aug 22, 2007 11:08 AM Permalink
where did u get information about points 1 ,2 and 3 in ur post? can u give ur sources so that the public can benefit? i myself dont know anything about those things.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by Suresh Verma on Aug 22, 2007 11:07 AM Permalink
Why so much discussion when you know CPI means Chinese Party in India.They claim that they are not corrupt but they do take money from China for Saleing there motherland.They raise quetion in parliament when US army do any thing in Iraq but never for Arunchal prades where China claims or some IAS were not given Visa to them since China claims that Aruncachal is part of China.They will call US in afganistan aggression but China in Tibbet as internal matter.FDI in India is ruining or indusrty & Coca Cola as playing with health of country but Cheap import from china as ok,dangerous materila & toy from China is good for poor who cannot affort.THEY ARE DOUBLE SPEAK PEOPLE.
RE:RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by dinesh kumar on Aug 22, 2007 11:10 AM Permalink
does the cpi really take funds from china? i was thinking that some fanatic anti left people were telling this,i never imagined that it could be true,please give more information on the matter.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by kraft on Aug 22, 2007 11:38 AM Permalink
Mr.Dinesh Kumar, Indira Gandhi complained about Communist Party of India to Moscow [it is on record]-to rein them in! How? Obviously by threstening to stop the Funds to the CPI from Russia and China!! What more proof do you want? Many of the so-called NGOs are existing not to "Serve the Poor" as they claim!
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by Sathish N on Aug 22, 2007 03:14 PM Permalink
That is Indira's mistake and not proof that CPI has anything to do with China. Ideas can originate in any part, it is for us to analyse and gain from it. I for sure an not a commie, but also do not like the hardcore capitalists who would not shy from enslaving others for personal gain. What we need is a balanced view.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by Sahadevan KK on Aug 22, 2007 12:45 PM Permalink
Those people attack Communist Partlies in many ways.
Somebody advertises Communist leaders are corrupted because they does like people do not compare each others. Somebody advertises Communism is not good, Democracy is good, what BJP says. Democracy is the best way to befool people and earn more and more money. Somebody advertises Communism is okay, Indian Communist Parties are not good because they cannot forget our 60 bad years . Somebody advertises Communist party is good, Communist leaders are not so good because they cannot ignore the development has been done. Somebody advertises some Communist Parties are good, but not others even then they are working together. Somebody advertises Communist Party is good, some leaders are also good, then try to attack other leaders which is last method and now doing.
All the above mentioned situations' aim is to attack the Communist Party and its leaders, to divert attraction of the common man.
But, today, people like the Communist Party and its leaders in entire India, because they think, they discuss, they do the same thing. Everything is for India's progress and integrity. Everything for poor people. Party's foundation is the mass support.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by Jiji on Aug 22, 2007 11:27 AM Permalink
1) The communists themselves were on hunt by the british before independance and by congress even after independance. 2) An actual communist doesn't believe in national boundaries.. the whole universe is his home. In that sense then Communist secretary EMS Namboodiripad said that the war is a fight between India and China for a piece of land. And this statement was successfully manipulated by media and congress. 3) Communists who stayed inside congress till 1930s are the ones who voted Netaji to the Congress president's post and Communists also helped Netaji to escape India from British. Ofcourse they called him a cheater when he only joined with Nasi Germany! But communists were always politically with Netaji and thats why Captain Laxmi Segal herself joined in CPIM and Forward Block (the party of Netaji) is in the Left block with communists. 4) If left is opposing deal not for national interest then what is BJP doing?????
RE:RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by kraft on Aug 22, 2007 11:43 AM Permalink
Mr.Jiji you expect us to believe the Thrash that you dish out? The Communists [being paid agents] faithfully followed Joseph Stalin by first opposing Britain and supporting the Nazis and later oppsed the Nazis when they turned against Russia!! Dont give Ideological Sugar-coating to Stooges of Foreign Interests.
RE:who exactly are these :Left ?
by Sreelekha Nair on Aug 22, 2007 10:49 AM Permalink
Very good job pulling the pages of history on the GREAT constribution that these CPI (read Chinese Party in India- CPI) has !
