The US says that the Nuclear deal will be scrapped if India conducts a Nuclear test. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh refutes this. What is correct ? The public have a right to know.
RE:RE:What is the truth ?
by Vishal Kale on Aug 16, 2007 12:34 PM Permalink
Is that the way your nation did it? No. Secondly, and far more pertinently, we are one of the very few nations that are surrounded by arch-enemies... CHINA and PAKISTAN. Our security needs are unique to us. You are only now facing terrorism... we have been doing so for at least 20 years. The number of innocent Indians dying to terorist acts outnumber the total number of american deaths to such causes by a multiple factor... You have had ONE SOLITARY ATTACK in your nation, for which you reduced Iraq to rubble. We have one such attack in every six months. Please refrain from commenting without complete knowledge. We need a powerfull and credible deterrent. Remember: Before we went nuclear, there was one major war every few years. There has yet to be one since we went overtly nuclear. I rest my case
RE:What is the truth ?
by hiral joshi on Aug 16, 2007 12:46 PM Permalink
again well said Vishal. Simulation is of no use without proper field data with pre-requisite accuracy and precision.
YOU CAN SIGN A TOTAL DEFENCE PACT WITH AMERICA LIKE TAIWAN, KUWAIT, ISRAEL ETC, THEN IF ANYONE ATTACKS YOU IT WILL BE EQUIVALENT TO ATTACKING AMERICA AND THE FULL FORCE OF THE AMERICAN MILITARY WILL BE USED TO DEFEND YOU.
RE:RE:What is the truth ?
by hiral joshi on Aug 16, 2007 12:48 PM Permalink
India dont want that. We did N-test despite of US pressures and excelled under the sanction era and now we are self-sufficient to defend us against China and Pakistan. If the time comes India should do N-test, may be this time an improved fusion device.
RE:What is the truth ?
by Vishal Kale on Aug 16, 2007 01:13 PM Permalink
Go to hell... we would rather die. But before we do, we will account for our enemies too.
RE:What is the truth ?
by vinay thakur on Aug 16, 2007 03:37 PM Permalink
Are you an American.If yes then you are again a fool.Your country is run by few handful of capitalists who organise WTO bombimgs and then on that pretext invades countries like Iraq for oil!Your shameless president and media (who call themsleves flagbearers of democracy)are silent of these issues and make laughable comments like we are pro-democracy and we are safeguarding interests of people in Iraq. What a laughable bunch of people Americans are.Whole world knows their Dadagiri and this is the right time that golbal power is shared by rising Asian powers like CHina and India.I think solidifying our relations with China would be more beneficial than running after USA who has sole aim of maximizing their benefits.Americans are the largest consumer of everything in this world despite the fact they are not producing all of it.Their masses have lived comfortbaly for last few decades on money earned from looting other countries.Now it is becoming difficult for them to survive,thanks to the pressure from China & India. While China they cannot even think of making trouble with,they are taming India so that it doesnot become a threat to their lavish lifestyle.
