US wants to clip the nuclear millitary power of India, and India wants to empower the nuclear capability through the Indo-US Nuclear deal. Americans are so clever and Indians are so much clever. Let the deal suceed or fail, nobody is going to be losser.
RE:Why should depend on US
by Golden on Apr 13, 2007 10:48 PM Permalink
yes.. now you understand the real face of USA. take some inspiration from Iran and behave like human to muslims. only muslims can defeat the US tyranny thats why i respect islam.
RE:Why should depend on US
by on Apr 13, 2007 08:58 PM Permalink
We need American help as well as others help for our growth, let us have more talks & make them understand our position.
RE:Why should depend on US
by on Apr 13, 2007 10:22 PM Permalink
I agree that there should be more talks , but the point is that when Indian demands are not met how can we expect to sign the deal?Remember, that US is aiming to bring India under NPT and CTBT which themselves are flawed.US is educated and advanced are accepted but that does not mean that we loose our senses to put our scientific community's freedom of research, on stake. Nations , at international fora, must be treated equally. Secondly, if the deal does not go through, US should not sulk and its wisdom will be tested if it still keeps a good relation with India. India has allowed for inspection for 14 of her nuclear plants. What more do you ask from India? Refusing nuclear fuel and reusing fuel is confinement of our freedom. US sulks when India trades with Iran but what about India who has been seeing US giving monetary support and past military support to Pakistan in past despite knowing the realities?Remember, the interests of our scientific community comes first. Manmohan Singh once quoted that if deal does not go through still India - US relations won't be affected - this statement itself testifies goodwill nature of India. On the other hand US politician loosing cool and warning us shows their immaturity. India can not be collared and sign the treaty under dueres.
RE:Why should depend on US
by on Apr 13, 2007 08:31 PM Permalink
World want India to be part of the world like others in this globalized ways. Let them change their position comes w/o any strings attached.
RE:Why should depend on US
by on Apr 13, 2007 08:29 PM Permalink
It is other ways round my brother, we need more electricity for the poor w/o compromising our national security, N-Deal is one of the good ways for producing electricity like other ways like thorium etc. We need more talks to explain our requirements to others.
RE:Why should depend on US
by Sivakumar Periasamy on Apr 13, 2007 09:54 PM Permalink
If US is really interested in providing techniques to improve the electricity production in our country, they can go for the deal without much restrictions on indian side. They want to get some dollars from the deal. If the scientific advancement is really meant for the welfare of human being, they can give it in free without restrictions. India never act as untrust partner in big deal, unlike other countries.
