Guys, Before talking about reservation...we have to see the matter in every angle....
God doesnt create particular section of the people as brainy....Every individual has his own talents....
Unfortunately/Fortunately the people who below poverty line are converted to muslims and cristians in india.
Before conversions they were more or less treated as slaves not even allowed to enter the temple or anything that sort. Education is not given to them at any stage and they have tilised by the rich people.
After the conversion they were atleast treated equally like others. Praise to GOD.
But as these people not exposed to education so many generation they became dull. Scentifically it is true also. Noone can call them brain-less, let GOD help us not saying that.
So these people cannot flourish in education or other things. So we have to provide them the QUOTA so that generation - 10 will be as euivalent other guys.
So TN CM has done great job by doing this. It may be for political reason but ETHIC wise we have to do that.
RE:[object MouseEvent]
by SaiSubramanyam Thoota on Apr 05, 2007 02:57 PM Permalink
As long as there are people like you, India cannot become a super power. People like u bring bad name to true Christians and Muslims.
RE:THINK!!!!
by SaiSubramanyam Thoota on Apr 05, 2007 02:56 PM Permalink
As long as there are people like you, India cannot become a super power. People like u bring bad name to true Christians and Muslims.
RE:THINK!!!!
by vijay baskar on Apr 05, 2007 02:58 PM Permalink
super power sai ?????? man wake up !!! didnt u read this article ? TN is heading towards SUPER FLOP and so in india
RE:THINK!!!!
by vijay baskar on Apr 05, 2007 03:01 PM Permalink
since u come to temple straight after doing VIBHACHARAM..we are in a position to see ABHACHARAM.. understood arun ?
RE:THINK!!!!
by Biswajit Ghoshal on Apr 05, 2007 03:11 PM Permalink
Ali - you said to look at it from every angle, but you yourself saw it from one angle only!!
1. Granting anything on the basis of religion is in direct contradiction of "equal rights for all" and secular concepts of the constitution of India.
2. If unmeritorious students/employees are taken in, the standards of education/job are bound to fall down - which will have very gravious effect on every aspect of society.
3. The backward people, who do not have any education OR very little education upto standard 4 or 8 will not be able to take advantage of higher-studies quota (requiring standard 12 study) or good jobs (mostly requiring graduation). Dull boys from affluent backward category will use those quota. The real backward people will remain backward only. Thereby the very purpose of quota, i.e. upliftment of the the backward, will be defeated.
After that what? 100% reservation?? Even that too will be used the same way only - and the backward people will remain backward. Hence quota should be immediately removed. Numerous programs for backward community should be strengthened. Quota will not and never help - except ensuring vote for the quota-maker parties.
RE:THINK!!!!
by Ibrahim Sheik on Apr 05, 2007 03:23 PM Permalink
CORRECTION Mr. JAWAHAR, ISLAM IS DIFFERENT FROM CHRISTIANITY, THE CONVERTS ARE NOT ONLY LOW CASTE HINDUS COMING INTO ISLAM, THE CONVERTS ARE FROM UPPER CASTES HINDUS ALSO. TAKE EXAMPLE OF AIYAMPETTAI TOWN IN THANJAVUR, THE PRESENT DAY MUSLIMS ARE ALL BRAHMINS BEFORE 100 YEARS.
