RE:FYIP
by Biswajit Ghoshal on Apr 02, 2007 02:40 PM Permalink
Yes - that's why it is undemocratic to give quota to any section of the society.
The main purpose of quota is to bring social justice to the poor. so to bring them up, free education and free higher education can be provided. If we don't do that, then even if we have quota, the poor people won't be able to reach the stage from where they can reap the benefits of quota. Instead, the creamy section of SC/ST/OBCs would continue the avail those benefits and fatten-up. With Quota-system in place, the main purpose of quota would be defeted.
RE:FYIP
by m on Apr 02, 2007 02:50 PM Permalink
Any rational person will compete with himself and not with others. A truly meritorious student will understand this.
RE:RE:FYIP
by Biswajit Ghoshal on Apr 02, 2007 03:45 PM Permalink
1. Before using logic which you might have mugged up elsewhere, check it's applicability. Cometition with self is for self-improvement. Whereas it is competition with others, when one is applying to some job or institute. Otherwise there would not have been anything called competitive examinations !!
2. If you really believe competition with self is for rational meritorious students, then do you say that is for only the general category students - and not for SC/ST/OBCs, because they are irrational and meritless - which is why they need reservation???
