Mr Krishnan started well in an attempt to describe the attitude of the left but went far away in tne end.Yes in a way his analysis on how to eveluate India of to- day is not far behind but I would like to make a point to add that :PROGRESS MUST BE WITHOUT ANY AVOIDABLE HINDERENCE:The left parties of India still think and aspire under the cloud of :MAKING POOR RICH BY MAKING RICH POORER: When are they going to understand that any attempt to provide benifits without any service or sacrifice in bound to be misused and make working hand cripple for ever.This is what our left parties want and make people live on doles.One can not appriciate present India staying in India but from abroad.To day India is noticed for her economic growth graph,techno- logical advancement and multitude of effective trained hand on science and technology.Inspite of their best effort no pressure from left can stop India moving ahead.All of us must see that present policy remain in place with eye on progress and prosperity to all.