I can not understand why this writer is so biased against Muslim that he wonder away from his main topic and started comparing genocide of jews with muslim rebellian in Kerala. If you want to know about greatest genocide and persecution in the world history ,there is no comparision to genocide and ultimate subjugation of Bhuddhist in India. This two thousand years of subjugation of Bhuddhist into Dalit in India paved way to rise of Islam in India. Now these people with same ideology are against Islam because they know that Islam stands to protect the week by giving them tools not to fall in trap of the vices created by today's gods. This writer has quitely forgetten that there are ten times more violent riots against minorities in India than in Pakistan or BanglaDesh
RE:Another Jalianwallah Bagh
by ajat on Aug 23, 2005 06:54 PM Permalink
Boss, This way anyone can preach that his religion is greatest the way U r saying about Islam. The issue is not about greatness of any religion but to ensure that such crimes against humanity are not repeated. Also God knows from where are u getting ur figures of more atrocities on minorities in India as against Pak or Bang.
RE:Another Jalianwallah Bagh
by Venkata Ramana on Aug 25, 2005 12:43 AM Permalink
Is that the reason why the hindu population is decreasing in Pakistan and Bangladesh? If the muslims are not being treated properly in India why do these millions of Bangladeshis come to India?
RE:Another Jalianwallah Bagh
by Chalam on Aug 27, 2005 05:53 AM Permalink
In no other country in the world, (including Islamic nations) Muslims enjoy as much respect, esteem and liberty as in India. We have had two Muslim Presidents. The present President is also a Muslim. Their grievances, if any, are imaginary and/or exaggerated. They should be proud to be an Indian Muslim.
Wake up Mr Shaikh
by Indian on Aug 23, 2005 07:44 PM Permalink
You seem to be in fools paradise or a staunch follower of imperialist way of stating false things repeatedly to make them true, however you are overdoing it too much. Everyone is aware of stats as to how many hindus Pakistan & Bangladesh had and how much is the progress(degress rather) in their numbers as compared to the way ethnic minorities have thrived in India. The point however is that the there are elements like you who instead of being thankful spit out venom against this great culture, thereby paving way to disasters. Mend your ways, thats all I can advise.
RE:Another Jalianwallah Bagh
by GNSaraswat on Aug 23, 2005 04:58 PM Permalink
(1) Rise in Islam was not necessariliy because of repression by Hindus. It was largely carried out at the point of sword by foreign aggressors (2) We cannot compare riots in Pakistan and Bangladesh because minorities in those coutries have been sytematically converted or eliminated. Sensus figures in both countries reflect these facts. (3) If one has to compare Pakistan, ook at the riots between Shias ad Sunnis. Look at the condition of otrher minorities like Ahmediayas and not Hindus. Let me state emphatically that Hindua have neven never been aggressors. Only now, they are become retaliators and unfortunately habitual aggressors finding it difficult to digest.
