So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu.they don't seem to belong to tamilnadu as they have come from africa 70,000 years ago. they probably spoke some african language initially for at least 65,000 years , tamil developed since last 5000 years. this proves that they are african origin not dravidians. no M130 marker found in rest of india, so other adivasis , tribals like Gonds , Bhills etc who are found in madhya pradeh, chattisgarh, orissa , maharashtra did not come from tamilnadu .this wholly shakes the dravidian argument.till now they claimed that dravidians lived all across india and later they were pushed down by aryans. this proves that non aryan people of rest of india are not neccessarily dravidians/africans. they are indegenious people of non-aryan,non-dravidian race.
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by san man on Apr 29, 2008 09:55 PM Permalink
moron bhejafry, the dravidian markers are present even in pakistan, that means dravidians were indeed the first population to settle in the indian subcontinent
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by BhejaFry on Apr 30, 2008 04:05 AM Permalink
M130 marker is a african marker, not dravidian marker. there is no evidence of dravidian race.
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by BhejaFry on Apr 30, 2008 04:15 AM Permalink
if dravidians lived all across india before the so-called aryan invasion, why according to the author, the M130 gene marker is not found outside tamilnadu ? in states like MP, Maha, Gujrat , Chattisgadh, orissa, jharkhand there is a huge tribal and adivasi population. if they were truly of dravidian/african origin then they should have found the m130 marker in them,but they havent. so i reiterate that non aryan people of rest of india are not neccessarily dravidians/africans. they are indegenious people of non-aryan,non-dravidian race.dravidians belong only to south india.they never lived throughout india. it was a macaulean theory to divide and rule.
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by Sudhakar Muthuknnan on Apr 29, 2008 09:30 PM Permalink
oh my god, Guys from north donot have any brain i guess. You freaking aryans ruined every bodies life with mis-interpretations and wrong ethics.
Scientist beleive he is the first immigrant man from Africa. I guess you know the meaning of immigrant.But he did not say he is the first Tamilian. Till now nobody proved the first man to step into indian Soil. But atleast Tamil nadu goes back 70000 years with rich history.
I have one serious question to everybody in this forum, Why everybody is against TN, Because of jeleous. We are the top 5 in all departments. even if the whole world hates us still we will be in top. Because we have our own thinking power, Knowledge and Self respect.
RE:RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by Sudhakar Muthuknnan on Apr 29, 2008 09:37 PM Permalink
Reply for your earlier message. HAHAHAHAHAH BhejaFry.... Eat food and sleep at home. Donot write some stupid sentences to the World wide Web. Remember whatever you write the whole world can read. So please write some sensible sentences.
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by sri on Apr 29, 2008 09:43 PM Permalink
The Aryan invasion theory has been strongly disproved by genetic evidence and the fact that there is no archaeological evidence. Even Marxists like Romila Thapar have now changed their views.
The only people hanging on to it for dear life are the linguists. But the point is that if for eg. German and Sanskrit are similar, why should it be that Europeans came to India? Why cant it be that Indians went to Europe?!
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by smart cbe on Apr 29, 2008 09:29 PM Permalink
FYI Every human being are migrants except for the ones in Africa. Ever heard of the term "Evolution"? Humans along with all living beings evolved depending on the environment and on the constraints nature posed on them. That's why you got the amazing diversity that the world currently holds. And some senseless morons discriminate others based on skin color, language, caste, religion and every goddamn thing you can think of. What is shocking is that it's not the illiterate crowd that discriminates. It's the so called "literate clowns" who claim to read and write but can't think for themselves and make a right judgment drives me nuts. Any racist retard using this forum to share their "intelligent insight" can go shove their head in your "you-know-where". Nobody can claim that they are the Native, Indigenous people of India. It's a FACT, live with it.
RE:So tamils are after all migrants in tamilnadu
by gac on Apr 29, 2008 09:26 PM Permalink
bheja, this article in other way means that tamilnadu is the first place to have human civilization in todays India. which in other ways proves that these mentioned M130 markers are the forefathers of the rest of indians.
