MR SEN you was questioning the logic of this movie and based on this you have given one star to this movie.
May I ask you waht did you find logical in OSO?
Had srk been the lead man in this movie you would have increased the no of stars for this movie
Indian movies never make any logic and will always be hyped
Most of the Indians dont have the abality to understand a good movie and in this country people like SRK will alawys be on top and talented people like shekhar kapoor will leave India and live abroad and contribute to west
RE:LOGIC?
by Rekha Menon on Nov 24, 2007 01:51 AM Permalink
OSO is a spoof - right from the begining you have to understand that the movie is making fun of everything. And once the viewer has got into that frame of mind, then you just go along with the second half reincarnation bit.Both SRK and Farah Khan didn't make any bones about the fact that they're making a fun movie with no pretensions to intellectualism or preaching. And as such, OSO is definitely watchable.
Dhoom 2 - a terrible movie in my eyes, was the same. All style and songs - no storyline.
GOAL is supposedly a 'serious' movie with a 'serious' message.But if the basic premise around the racism bit is ridiculous and illogical, then watching such a movie becomes intolerable.
Why Shekhar Kapoor has left India isn't becos is a different stor
RE:RE:LOGIC?
by Maninder Singh on Nov 24, 2007 09:02 AM Permalink
No, you will not be allowed to have the last word, partly because it's wrong, and partly because it's silly.
RE:LOGIC?
by Maninder Singh on Nov 24, 2007 01:43 AM Permalink
When something illogical is created with a tongue-in-cheek approach that says "Hey, look this is illogical" - then the entire work acquires logic, as is the case in OSO. But when there is sincerity in the illogical then it remains illogical, because the sincerity says "Look this is logical", whereas it, in reality, isn't. So the whole product is therefore, illogical. That is the difference.
