Guru was rated ok, but salaam e ishq was rated awesome. Remember that you are rating for the general public....not for fans of the comic series or some guy who has made the movie itself. Atleast a disclaimer saying only for the fans would have been better...otherwise 2 is what this deserves being sympathetic`
RE:Your reviews are simply pathetic....
by Aditya Singh on Feb 25, 2007 03:15 PM Permalink
Dude, forget the general public, Salaam-e-ishq was a pathetic movie for any public, be it the masses or the classes. And GURU was one of the best movies of Bollywood in recent time, let alone this year. GURU is a classy movie which was also liked by the masses & the general public.
RE:RE:Your reviews are simply pathetic....
by Indian on Feb 26, 2007 03:35 AM Permalink
Guru was not a classy movie by any means. Classy movies don't need Mallika Sherawat and heroine singing and dancing in rain. It was decent movie spoiled by commericial indulgence. I hate when directors like Maniratnam's caliber do things like this. I agree with your point that Guru is best movie this year but not "CLASSY" at all.
RE:RE:Your reviews are simply pathetic....
by yajuvender chauhan on Mar 08, 2007 02:35 AM Permalink
aditya please come out of your dreams...Abhishek bachchan & Aishwarya rai can never give you classy movies...it was ok movie
