ok enough srk bashing i guess. people say that they couldn't tolerate him in don. but according to me he did a descent enough job. now let us imagine amitabh in ddlj...let us try to put a young amitabh in the role of raj. do you guys think that amitabh would have done justice to the role as beautifully as srk did? do yoou guys think that amitabh could have (when he was younger of course) potrayed the role of rahul in kuch kuch hota hai or in dil to pagal hai. could amitabh have done a darr?!! i dont get it....why do people have to say that srk cant to amitabh...now my question is...can amitabh be srk?!! well at least srk can try and maybe even suceed in roles, amitabh essayed...but amitabh can never ever potray the roles of srk....so who is greater after all....imagine amitabh in energetic romantic roles (i repeat when he was young)....could he be as charming as srk... i hope the people grow up really and stop comparing them...how many people compare frank sinatra from ocean's twelve with george clooney...the people of this country really need to grow up..do you guys even remember amitabh from lal badshah...what do you say about that...or bade mian, chote mian, where even govinda overshadowed him...and now talk about screen presence...!! srk is srk and amitabh is amitabh...they are different....but srk in my personal opinion has a definite edge over amitabh as far as variety goes...
RE:Amitabh in DDLJ
by Shanti Nair on Feb 09, 2007 02:36 PM Permalink
Have you seen the original DON ? It was an Amitabh film all the way ? The replica DON was a gadget and gizmo gimmickry show all the way. You are a SRK fan so you liked the movie but it was wanst liked by many and hence it was only an average success inspite of some real innovative marketing. SRK needs to watch out as hes yet to give real solo hit since 2004 while his competitors like Amir and Hritik are giving super hits once after the other.
SO far as doing a DDLJ or KKHH is concerned , have you heard of Khuddaar,Amar Akbar Anthony, Naseeb, Satte pe Satta , Mr Natwarlal , Suhaag, Hera Pheri which bring out the lighter side of the Big B ? So far as Darr is concerned , have you seen Parvana because you will see the difference between a class act from a raw amitabh and a mediocre one from a raw SRK ?
RE:Amitabh in DDLJ
by Neeraj Satija on Feb 10, 2007 11:53 AM Permalink
r u kidding? Amitabh did Silsila, which is considered the ultimate romantic movie of all time. have you not heard "Yeh Kahan aa gaye hum" or "Rang Barse" or seen those amazing histrionics!! AB can do everything that loser SRK can do & much much more....there is no comparison. AB is in a different league all together.
Speaking of SRK, can he do what Aamir did in Rakh or Rangeela. Or what Salman did in Judwaa or Hum Aapke Hain Kaun? When SRK can't be the best of his time, how can you compare him with the best of all time (AB)?
RE:RE:Amitabh in DDLJ
by ashutosh gupta on Feb 10, 2007 12:26 PM Permalink
Very well said Neeraj, and let us not forget Kabhi Kabhi and Muquaddar ka sikandar. Amitabh is ultimate superstar and SRK is just a mimic or a follower of Amitabh and that is why he keeps on trying to imitate Amitabh be it Don or KBC or some ads...
RE:Amitabh in DDLJ
by Anamika Arora on Feb 09, 2007 11:00 AM Permalink
well said i love them both ........a lot..........y do their fans have to fight with each other???????????????
RE:RE:Amitabh in DDLJ
by MANOJ ASOPA on Feb 09, 2007 11:34 AM Permalink
my dear anurag AB can't do those as u have asked for actually he need not to do because by palying a cow boy type roles one can be charming but he could never be a superstar because superstar need a different credentials which SRK does not have. this is the fact.So pls advice SRK to do the same roles. manoj asopa
