Sachin did accept the vice captainship earlier ! He is also reported to be unhappy at the treatment being meted out to the seniors ! And the delayed refusal ! All these clearly point to two things: one, poor communication between BCCI and the players. Two, that the seniors are under intense pressure to perform in view of the resounding performance from the youngsters. Now, let us analyze their recent performance : the three greats with more than a decade of experience each and more than 35,000 runs in their bags, could they win the series for India against the Aussies ? No. could they draw the series for India ? No. Did they contribute in the two wins ? Perhaps, yes, to a limited extent but nothing spectacular or noteworthy. Even if they had not been there may be the results could have been equally good or bad with all youngsters ! Then why carry this EXCESS BAGGAGE for the one dyers and delay building up a younger team ? Why deny opportunities to budding youngsters who are excelling and are ready to take over ? Incidentally this PAK team is weak and the seniors may find it easy. But it is also the best opportunity to expose the youngsters towards preparation for the tough Aussie series. Is there any doubt that the Aussie series will only further confirm that the seniors are indeed EXCESS BAGGAGE for the one dayers ?
RE:EXCESS BAGGAGE
by Sanjeev Verma on Nov 07, 2007 07:26 PM Permalink
Natwest Series (Against England : Summer) Matche s Runs Highest Average Strike Rate SR Tendulkar (India) 7 374 99 53.42 85.77
Yuvraj Singh (India) 7 283 72 40.42 86.01
SC Ganguly (India) 7 249 72 35.57 73.45
R Dravid (India) 7 223 92* 37.16 97.37
MS Dhoni (India) 7 175 50 25.00 72.31
Future Cup (Against South Africa: Summer)
SR Tendulkar (India) 3 200 99 66.66 77.82
Yuvraj Singh (India) 3 123 61* 123.00 78.34
R Dravid (India) 3 112 74 37.33 73.68
SC Ganguly (India) 3 73 42 24.33 60.33
MS Dhoni (India) 2 14 14* 14.00 93.33
Look at averages of Dhoni in an overseas tour. Only Yuvraj graduated to be in the same league as our seniors
RE:EXCESS BAGGAGE
by Reza Arif on Nov 07, 2007 06:46 PM Permalink
I hope the Seniors are rested for the Aussie ODI's and if required for the Test Matches too .. At least then we will come to know the truth .. & I am guessing that the truth will be "THAT THE SENIORS ARE INVALUABLE FOR THE TEAM RIGHT NOW .. THERE IS NO APT REPLACEMENT FOR THEM YET"
Just look at the previous series statistically..
In the Aussie series .. In the series in England & Ireland ...
Was Yuvraj the highest run getter or was it Dhoni or was it Uthappa or any other youngster?
The Seniors were on top .. and when these folks like Yuvi & dhoni themselves are not able to eclipse the seniors .. what will rookie players like Badrinath & Tiwari do?? I am not counting them off .. but very little chances of them able to hold their places...
