I totally agree with your views! Vishal is a very balanced judge on show! I have observed couple of times his facial expressions when HR raises the love story issue, which talks lot about his personality. I also appreciate his courage when he said ' love story or not i don't care ...full 10 marks'. In several occuassions this guy has given back for HR's idiotic comments/judgement! Its aslo worth mentioning here the way he quits arguing with HR bocz its nothing but waste of time!