Well, he is not a muslim because rabid muslims are unable to argue in writing. When some one throws mud at Hinduism by misquoting holy Hindu texts, he is most likely a Christist, an evil evangelical who worships a mythical dead corpse of a dead jew stuck up a wooden cross. He is most likely a low-caste convert who was brain-washed by the priest who abused him and his sister and paid him money to convert.