I quite agree Tarun with your logic. A proud Bengali should live in Bengal, a Proud Tamilian in Tamilnadu etc. If take it to the extremes, no villager should migrate to the towns. India has always been a land that has accepted migrants and so has America comparatively recently. Regarding Shivai, no one should say she cjhose to migrate. Her father/mother migrated. Just because she was born in States, she may not have 'Indianness'. It's only those jelous people who have not been able to migrate and win laurels comment adversely about people like Shivani. India should be improving facilities right from the primary stage, so that we do not need reservations, and thus improve the opportunities so that people stay in India.