Well, I have gone through various scriptures of different religions, and almost everyone makes assumptions without any general merit. For e.g Hinduism concept of rebirth does not have any rational merit. It is imprudish to jump to conclusions saying only Hinduism provides a path to liberation and rest are damned like the Christian concept of beleif in Christ is the only route to salvation. The reason I recommned Hinduism is not proper religion for India is it never was an unifying force, atleast may be Christianity and Islam might. I do not endorse these religions either as these religions too have many flaws only atleast there is some common thread among those who beleive in these religions. Who is an Hindu is one of the tough questions to answer. A person could be Hindu even if he not believe in vedas or any major scripture. Who is there to say certain such people are Hindus because they follow certain things. All Indians are Hindus ... only thing non muslims and non christians are ones without any religion.