The expulsion shows that the party has no concern for either constitutional legal position or the popular perception in this regard. As a Speaker Chatterjee wanted to show that he could never act according to the dictates of the party. He is one of the best parliametarians from CPM. His character is impeccable. He has always participated in useful discussions in the parliament. Conducted the proceedings in an exemplary manner.CPM;s action will bring only furthr discredit to the party and not Mr Chatterji. thiagarajan P