Who cares if there is a benefit for the US, is there benefit to us should be our only yarstick to decide. The deal is being discussed for the last one year, if that is not in public then what is ? where are the BJP getting details of the "Hyde act" and opposing it if the deal is not public and is secret, half knowledgable asses like you are the reason there is confusion, and not because the facts are not out there, just that some peoples politics interferes with their IQ.