Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Is Somnath Chatterji right?
by VASUDEVAN V on Jul 21, 2008 10:12 AM

Neerja Chowdhury has certainly presented her view points about Somnath Chatterji as Speaker in the right perspective. However,is Somnath Chatterji right in making the statement that he does not want to appear to be voting with the BJP, a communal party. In other words, does he mean to say that if there was no BJP in the picture, he would have resigned as Speaker and voted with his party against the UPA government? That is the million dollar question. Obviously, it means that his assertion of Speaker being neutral is secondary to his disinclination to vote with BJP. Going by this interpretation, it proves that Somnath Chatterji is a humbug, resting on his laurels as an outstanding Parliamentarian of 40 years standing. There is also one more point I would like to emphasise. By saying that BJP is communal and he would not want to be seen to be voting with them, he has proved his bias beyond doubt and to say he was neutral as a Speaker or will be neutral in future, including in the Trust Vote, is questionable. It will be honourable for him to resign both as Speaker and as a MP so that he will not be present in the Parliament during the Trust Vote. I, as a supporter of BJP, strongly object to his statement, as it insults me as a voter. Remember, crores of Indians who vote for BJP are not communal. If they are communal, just imagine what will happen to the fabric of our society. Stop insulting us, you dirty politicians!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Speaker episode: Tip of CPI-M iceberg