Its all can be argued the way in which you want to argue. The very fact is had Mr. Chatterji did not win Lok Sabha seat on Left seat, he would not have become a speaker. By taking this stand, he defies the people who vote for left and elected him to Lok Sabha. Its a clear Breach of Trust. The reason he attributes is totally absurd. Its because of left's withdral of support the current scenerio is created. Its not because of BJP brought in no confidence motion. Who knows? Is it yet another 25C matter? I dont believe so taking into calibre of Mr. Chatterji. He took advise of his close political guru Mr. Basu and set aside his advice too.