yes jamsheed the BJP having won 130 seats during last election should sit quietly at the Parliament and they did not have any moral right to act as an opposition party simply because they are not adapt to the "secularism" being practiced by other political parties in the country. Who are they to reflect the sentiments of another section of voters in the country. All should follow the "secular" concept propounded by Congress, Lefts and other regional parties and must keep BJP, which is bold enough to raise its voice for majority community in the country. Further, I do suspect that Karat might have fallen victim to ideologies of BJP simply because he was given more powers to take decisions on his own. He should also have been made as a puppet. But it is too late. Hope my views also as confusing as yours bu at the same time hitting out at BJP without sense or any reason