I can understand why Dr. MMS found the principle behind the Indo-US Deal attractive. He has done the right thing by pursuing this Deal. BUT, now that the details are emerging, Dr.MMS and the UPA must spend MORE TIME in negotiations to CLARIFY matters vital for India. No harm in getting the Deal passed in the next US Administration. India must NOT rush itself.
There is a danger that India would be caught in much legal wranglings with both the USA and IAEA - unless it takes time to CLARIFY the points that these learned scientists have raised in the main essay.