Lots of Forum participants tend to mix up and talk extreme things either for or against the nuclear deal.
We must clearly understand that 123 agreement is for civilian use of nuclear technologies and resources.
And USA simply wants India to ratify that.
This is the reason we are clearly separating the reactor for Civilian uses and military uses for the International audience.
Our civilian reactors would be for International scrutiny. But not the reactors for military use.
We have to have clear "audit process" for the resources bought under 123 agreement.
We do not have such obligation for our reactors for military use and resources obtained from outside the 123 agreement.
The agreement text has been vetted by even BJP politicians and have praised in private.
The communists do not have any objections and all their 9 points have been addressed adequately by Indian negotiators.
But the actual story is different.
BJP needs to oppose. Because this has been secured for India by Sonia Gandhi and her team.
The communists need to oppose. Because they still can not do business with Amerians, even though China is a great beneficiary of American Wealth in today's time.
Who cares for the nation ?
The party is bigger than the Nation.
And some lunatics having great time and having a party seeing the Government of the day is not able to honour its International treaty.