What is wrong in this trade? Kidney is not extracted by force or by kidnapping, it is a deal in between a poor fellow and needy through doctor where doctor is a big beneficiary. Govt. could not provide/eradicate poverty in the last 60 years of independence, everyone is minting money, nobody is caring to provide at least minimum guaranteed employment. Even if you punish Dr.Kidney Kumar, this may give temporary relief but trade will remain, if not in Delhi/Nodia -somewhere else