Your point is very valid. All hypocritic govts. since independence proclaim that J&K in an inalienable part of India but other than natural citizens of J&K every Indian is an alien in that state. What an irony! By the same logic, what is wrong when Shivsena wants Mumbai only for Maharashtrians. Why then the stupid politicians, including the courts come out and proclaim that Indians can live and work anywhere in India. I think as long as Indians are not allowed to settle and live in J&K, Pakistan and their stooges in J&K are perfectly right to proclaim that state does not belong to India.