Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
RE:Hindu Man Beheaded for marrying a muslim girl
by a m on Aug 03, 2008 06:08 PM


There is persistent confusion between the actions of
a Religion, and the actions of those who happen to
be of that Religion.

The people who beheaded, etc., were obviously very
ignorant, with lot of superstitions, and easily
misled. They were probably very poor. I believe that
it is illogical to demand responsible behavior of
a person brought up in such conditions. It is more
logical to condemn the Society that forces some
members to live in such conditions.

Their actions need not be seen in a Religious
light. They are not the organized, educated,
well informed representatives of their Religion.

Responsible, logical actions are what Society has
a right to expect of those for whom the Society has
arranged reasonable protection, well being, etc. If
an extremely poor man kills someone, then regardless
of motive or circumstance he should be immune from
punishment. At the most we should take preventive
action against repetition, but should not condemn
him or imply that he did wrong. If some "well fed"
person sent him to do the murder, it is that second
person who should hang and not the one who actually
killed.

Right and Wrong begin after the stomach is full,
not when it is empty.

Ignorant, deprived, narrow minded people can be of
any Religion, and their actions can be very bad, but
it has little to do with the Religion.

Rather we should try to identify those behind such
things, who try to exploit such people for their
own narrow ends.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Pakistan PM promises probe into Kabul at